‘Trumpism’ is not enough of a mass movement to be fascism, visiting professor says

US' current political context does not fit traditional fascism, sociology professor Dylan Riley says

· Apr 3, 2019 Tweet

Molly DeVore/The Badger Herald

A sociology professor at the University of California-Berkeley, spoke Wednesday to discuss why he doesn’t believe President Donald Trump is a fascist.

Professor Dylan Riley began the talk — the second of a three-part series hosted by the Havens Wright Center for Social Justice — by saying there is a lot of concern that fascism is on the rise because of the Trump administration.

But, Riley said we should look at Trump differently.

“’Trumpism,’ whatever that turns out to be, is not even an emergent form of fascist rule,” Riley said. “I’m going to suggest instead that this is a form of what I’m going to call neo-Bonapartist patrimonialism.”

Neo-Bonapartist patrimonialism is Trump’s direct relationship — “unmediated by thought” — with his supporters. The relationship demands loyalty to his personal power, Riley said, but Trumpism is different from fascism. 

Trump signs executive order requiring colleges to protect free speech, or risk losing federal fundingPresident Donald Trump signed an executive order March 21 requiring colleges to protect free speech on campus or risk losing Read…

First, fascism and Trumpism developed differently, Riley said. Throughout history, fascism has developed when there is a strong working class population and a weak capitalist population.

The U.S. does not have this kind of political structure, he said. 

“The situation, of course, in the contemporary U.S bears basically no similarity to this at all,” Riley said. “We have two essentially capitalist parties that have dominated politics in this country for decades. This is really an entirely different kind of political context than what you get in the classic fascist cases.”

Second, the U.S. does not have the right geopolitical structure to nurture fascism, Riley said.

Fascism traditionally occurred in imperialistic countries that fueled their land-grabs with frequent military drafts. The U.S., a declining empire that’s not seeking to amass land and whose politicians are averse to drafts, can’t foment the same radical mass movements, he said.

Because fascist regimes are focused on accumulating land and “overturning the international order,” Trump’s approach to international relations are not fascist, Riley said. Trump is focused more on conserving the U.S.’ current land and power and stays relatively uninvolved in international politics, unlike other, more traditional fascist leaders. 

Trump rallies for Walker, Vukmir — promises job creation, immigration control, healthcare reformPresident Donald Trump campaigned for Republican candidates at the Central Wisconsin Airport Wednesday night and discussed issues like jobs and Read…

It is important to differentiate between Trumpism and fascism, Riley said, because it shows there isn’t an established system of “Trumpists.”

“We shouldn’t be thinking about why are there some people who seem fanatically devoted to Trump,” Riley said. “What we should be thinking about is how could the political system be so deflated that this person who, many of his voters don’t even particularly like, somehow got into the White House?”

A key distinction between fascism and Trumpism is that traditional fascism is a reaction to the left, while Trumpism developed because the U.S. lacks a strong left, Riley said. While there may be a core of devoted Trumpists, his followers do not make up the type of mass movement required by fascism. 

Because Trumpism is not a mass movement, it is easier to change the minds of its supporters.

“There’s not an ideology that’s holding them all together, which in a sense is a somewhat hopeful message,” Riley said. “I believe these people are transformable through some sort of process of political education.”


This article was published Apr 3, 2019 at 9:32 pm and last updated Apr 3, 2019 at 9:32 pm


UW-Madison's Premier Independent Student Newspaper

All Content © The Badger Herald, 1995 - 2023