City officials unanimously voted against a resolution prohibiting individuals from sleeping or lying down on public sidewalks during a Homeless Issues Committee meeting Monday.

The committee voted 9-0 to reject the resolution.

The resolution concerned the Central Business District Area, including any areas containing city offices between 7 a.m. and 10 p.m. If found in violation of the ordinance for the first time, officers would give a verbal warning to the respective individuals.

If individuals continue with the prohibited activities, however, they would be subject to a $10 fine for a first-time offense in the given year and a $25 fine for a second or subsequent offense within that same year.

Council members, mayor clash over proposed homeless ordinanceThe Madison City Council struggled to decide whether to live in an “and world” or an “or world” when discussing the Read…

Members were mainly concerned for the homeless community, whom the ordinance would most likely affect. The pattern of displacement that would have resulted if the ordinance passed particularly concerned committee members.

The pattern of displacement refers to when homeless individuals find themselves repeatedly forced to move to other neighborhoods.

County Board Sup. Heidi Wegleitner, District 2, said though no lawful alternatives exist, the city needs to address homelessness in more humane ways.

Committee members also said the ordinance contributes to “criminalizing homelessness.”

Soglin plans to reintroduce ordinance to limit downtown sleeping hoursMayor Paul Soglin plans to reintroduce his controversial ordinance that would ban individuals from sleeping on downtown sidewalks, despite Madison Read…

“If the homeless are not able to pay the fine, do we put them in jail?” committee member Linda Ketcham said.

The committee also highlighted the need for the federal government to consider “housing instead of handcuffs” as alternatives to homelessness.

Committee members also took issue with the time frame, considering some homeless people work late shifts. In the face of severe housing insecurities, many homeless resort to sleeping in places like parks, city sidewalks or benches.

Committee member Ulysses Williams, who was previously homeless, said it can be difficult for homeless people to get enough sleep.

“They are going to need sleep one way or another,” Williams said. “I know it’s an eye sore, but they have the right to sustain life, which means they also have the right to sleep more than four hours.”