Opinion

Peaceful protest necessary, effective form of dialogue

Last Sunday on his blog, historian of student activism and student government Angus Johnston cited Wisconsin State Statute 36.09(5): “The students of each institution or campus subject to the responsibilities and powers of the board, the president, the chancellor, and the faculty shall be active participants in the immediate governance of and policy development for such institutions. As such, students shall have the primary responsibility for the formulation and review of policies concerning student life, services, and interests… The students of each institution or campus have the right to organize themselves in a manner they determine and to select their representatives to participate in institutional governance.”

Though this statute wasn’t passed until 1974, students have been taking a stand for what they believe in for decades. In the ’60s, students protested the presence of campus recruiters from the Dow Chemical Company that made the napalm used in the Vietnam War. Last fall the Student Labor Action Coalition held a teach-in at Chancellor Biddy Martin’s office protesting the school’s contract with Nike apparel due to their mistreatment of workers in Honduras. And just last week, students rallied together to object Bradley Smith’s Holocaust denial ad, which was placed in the Badger Herald.

Badgers aren’t the only ones taking a stand for causes that they believe in. Last Thursday, UW-Milwaukee’s Students for a Democratic Society organized what they had planned to be a peaceful demonstration in response to massive budget cuts. The protest, which started in California, was part of a national day of action to defend education.

The issues these students and organizations are calling attention to are not problems exclusive to certain groups; they are issues that affect student bodies on the whole. For example, the UW-Milwaukee students called for a tuition freeze and for head university officials to take salary cuts before cutting the salaries of lesser-paid faculty. Tuition price tags and professors’ salaries are not the causes of a single radical group craving attention; they are the issues of a collective entity, student populations that are striving for equality and quality of education.

However, the responsibilities Statute 36.09(5) dictates — that students have to “formulate and review policies concerning student life, services, and interests and to organize themselves in a manner that they determine” — in no way gives students a right to gather and protest in a manner that is anything other than peaceful.

The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported police officers “had to use pepper spray to help break up a rally at the campus after some protestors became violent while trying to enter the building that contains the chancellor’s office.” UW-Milwaukee Spokesperson Tom Luljak said in a statement released to the press that after being turned away, “some protestors began throwing punches and tossing chunks of ice.”

This is inexcusable. The right to protest and the right to free speech are freedoms students across the country are proud to have. When a person or organization abuses those rights, it reflects poorly on others who are making constructive and peaceful objections to matters they disagree with. Violence, in any shape or form, whether provoked or not, is not the answer. On another level, because the protest in Milwaukee got a little out of hand, the majority of the news headlines are reading, “Pepper spray used to break up UWM protest,” and “Tuition protest at UW-Milwaukee turns violent; 15 detained after scuffling with police.” The focus thus became the violence instead of their cause — exactly the opposite of what the students wanted.

There is power in organized activism. The UW-Madison students who rallied last Wednesday on Library mall were peaceful. The panel held to discuss journalistic ethics and sensitivity in response to the placement of Smith’s Holocaust denial ad was peaceful. The students who marched into our Chancellor’s office were peaceful. And guess what? With peace come results. Members of SLAC have opened up a doorway to discussion with Biddy Martin and have brought attention to their efforts to sever the University’s ties to Nike as long as it continues to treat its workers unfairly.

Nelson Mandela once said, “One of our strongest weapons is dialogue.” Conversation sparks change. Perseverance, dedication and the will to stick to your guns even when change is not immediate are what lead to reform.

The students who protested at UW-Milwaukee, UC-Berkeley, and all the other universities across the nation last week are taking part in actions that date back to generations before us. Student activism is alive and thriving on the lawns of educational institutions around the country. It takes courage and organization to get a group of people together to fight for a cause, but it is those who face opposition with a sense of responsibility and with the mindset of peace that will bring about the biggest change.

Chelsea Lawliss (lawliss@wisc.edu) is a sophomore intending to major in journalism.

Have a thought? We welcome your input, but please be polite and stay on topic wherever possible. Your comment may be deleted if it is inappropriately off topic or promotional or if it is unnecessarily rude or contains personal attacks. We may delete comments for other reasons as well. Just keep it simple and focus on your points as respectfully as possible.

We allow and encourage comments employing satire, wit and irony to make points. Do not flag comments just because you disagree. Flagged comments will be immunized from further flagging unless they stray far from the guidelines and do not add to the discussion. Before flagging a comment you think is offensive, consider your time might be better spent rebutting it than censoring it.

blog comments powered by Disqus

7 older comments

user-pic

Poor example: Nelson Mandela once said, �One of our strongest weapons is dialogue.� Naturally, that did not preclude the grand wizard of “rehabilitated” terrorists from using other “weapons” in his terrorist arsenal… from bombing innocents to necklacing victims.

Try harder to cite a figure worth emulating.

Don’t be naive’. These Leftist-fascists are schooled in the art of political extortion by domestic terrorism… and let’s not be cute, assaulting peace officers to achieve your political agenda is domestic terrorism. Witness also the planned domestic terrorism by Leftist-fascists at the 2008 RNC Convention.

The SDS have a sordid history of domestic terrorism that reaches to the ObaMao White House.

It isn’t just “inexcusable”… it is orchestrated political extotion by domestic terrorists and should be prosecuted as such.

user-pic

Money for nothing and their chicks for free!

THAT’S what the spoiled brats really want. Why should some poor prole have to pay higher taxes so the disaffected youth can “find themselves” at low, low prices?

user-pic

While I truly appreciate your effort to encourage more peaceful activism at UW, I think you should have done more research about the SLAC teach-in (which occurred this Spring semester actually) and the UW-Milwaukee protest before writing this article.

I would recommend consulting other sources in addition to a mainstream media outlet like the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel before blaming the protesters for the violence that occurred. Notice that the only person (other than Nelson Mandela) that you quoted in your article was the Vice-Chancellor of UW-Milwaukee, one of the many members of the administration who refused to meet with the organized body of concerned students on March 4. Luljak (as well as the typically reactionary Journal Sentinel) clearly has an interest in convincing the public that students initiated the violence by “throwing punches and tossing chunks of ice” because it serves as a distraction from the reasonable demands of the students and the incredibly unreasonable reaction from the campus police and the university administration.

As a person that was present at the rally last Thursday, I can say that I was truly disgusted by the way campus police treated the members of the UW-Milwaukee community. I saw them pepper spray people in the mouths and eyes without warning. I saw them throw knees and punches at students who remained nonviolent. I saw them arrest people who were just there to report for campus media, others who were there representing their union, and others who were not even involved in the protest (See this video http://sds-mke.blogspot.com/2010/03/student-journalist-being-arrested-from.html ). And finally I saw them tackle and arrest 16 people who were just trying to enter a public campus building to speak with their chancellor.

No I didn’t throw any snowballs or “chunks of ice” and I certainly didn’t punch any police. In fact, I didn’t see a single person get violent with police and as far as snowballs go… I’m sure no more than a couple of people threw snowballs and this was after police had assaulted a peaceful crowd. I’m not condoning the throwing of snowballs and I don’t think any of the organizers would, but I think the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel has egregiously misrepresented what occurred on March 4th, and by not consulting actual witnesses, you have perpetuated this mistake in your article.

With this criticism aside though, I’d like to thank you for your attempt here to remind readers of the power of peaceful protest. I certainly agree with you that the snowballs, despite the actions of the police, should not have been thrown. Violence does not help our cause. But I also think that what constitutes “violence” deserves elaboration. Were students being violent, for instance, when they continued to march forward toward the door of the administration building? The police and administration are trying to argue that they were. I’d argue (and I believe that Ghandi would agree) that this would be better defined as civil disobedience or direct action. Students had no intention of inflicting harm, yet they would not simply give up on their demands when confronted with opposition. I personally think students need to continue with peaceful yet forceful actions as you’ve indicated in this article to get their demands heard. Outside of a couple of idiots with snowballs, I think the UWM students did just that. Now if we could only teach our police force to be peaceful…

These Leftist-fascist mobs enjoy the spotlight their riots bring; but howl like dogs when peace officers do their duty. If you don’t want wood shampoos, then obey lawful orders and never assault the police— it’s that simple.

Lay down with dogs, wake up with fleas.

user-pic

83b6c53e…

You’ve written three equally ridiculous comments on this article thus far. Care to give it up yet? Or perhaps you could just make a real contribution to this discussion. Clown.

Thanks for the Pokemon logic, 719f168e. I cite EVIDENCE of SDS domestic terrorism (along with some healthy advice on avoiding wood shampoos)… and you sneer “ridiculous” and pretend that contributes.

Grade: F (miserable failure)

/dismissed

Donate