Opinion

Obama has a Nobel Prize? Where’s Vin Diesel’s Oscar?

Zach Day
Sharing tools:

E-mail this article:




Vote 0 Votes

Martin Luther King Jr., Mohamed Anwar Al-Sadat, Mother Teresa and Barack Obama all have something in common. For 108 years, the Nobel Peace Prize has honored the most humane, worldliest and most respected humans of the century. All of these individuals have received that honor. Martin Luther King Jr. was the face of a movement for equal rights among all people. His inspiration helped create a more tolerant world. His actions to end the Vietnam War were admirable and his belief in détente helped defuse the Cold War. Mohamed Anwar Al-Sadat, with fellow Nobel laureate Menachem Begin, helped promote peace in the Middle East with the Camp David Agreement. Mother Teresa is among the greatest humanitarians ever. Her efforts to take care of the sick and diseased in India led to her beatification in the Catholic Church. President Barack Obama has… been in office for 10 months.

Barack Obama has nothing on his résumé that would make him equal in that community. These are people who have done great things in their life and Barack Obama has the rest of his ahead of him. I am not saying that Obama will not “strengthen international diplomacy and cooperation between people.” I am saying that he hasn’t done much yet. At the very least, not enough to warrant a Nobel Peace Prize.

If the Norwegian Nobel Committee believes he is worthy of this honor, can they explain how the commander and chief of the U.S military during a war can “strengthen international diplomacy?” I would better understand that statement if our president pulled his troops out of the Middle East the first two months he was in office (like he promised). I would even understand that statement if he actually did something to progress the end of the war. Instead, he sends some more troops. I would not consider that humane, worldly or respectful.

The fact this Nobel Peace Prize is more of a hope than an accomplishment takes away from the grandeur of the award. This prize is an expectation for Obama to live up to instead of an honor. It’s almost shameful they reduced this prestigious award to a bet — a bet on whether Obama can live up to it. Our president now has a bigger burden and I hope he is ready for it.

According to the committee, the only way to become a Nobel laureate is to be nominated by a scholar or a so-called “respected person.” Their process starts in September, where they formally ask for nominations from those individuals qualified to nominate. In February, they collect all nominations and begin to decide on a short list of candidates. Over the next eight months, they interview and decide on the winners, who they announce in October. The process in which they do it is simple, but according to that time frame, Barack Obama was most likely nominated before he took office. Even if someone nominated him on Feb. 1, the last day to nominate, he would only be in office for 11 days. Only relying on his word for how and why he is going to “strengthen international diplomacy and cooperation between people” is insufficient justification for receiving such an award.

If that is the case — the award was given out of hope for plans he wishes to enact — then there should be more Nobel Peace Prizes given out. I would like to nominate our chancellor, Biddy Martin, for her promise to keep this university diverse and further promote equality not just on our campus, but in our classes as well. Her example of keeping an open mind to all is one that we should all learn, and will learn here at UW. Therefore, because she says this and also believes it, she deserves a Nobel Peace Prize. Also, I would like to nominate the jazz saxophonist who plays in the evening outside the University Bookstore across from Memorial Library. Not only is he bringing joy to those who listen to him, but he also provides a service in relaxing me after I get done studying intensely for a couple hours at the library. Because of his humanitarianism, he also deserves a Nobel.

I am perplexed why this award was given to Obama. I understand we’re all putting a lot of faith in him and I really wish him well. However, at least wait a year into his term to award him with anything. Otherwise, you are demoting the Nobel Peace Prize to the equivalent of a participation award.

Zach Day (zday@wisc.edu) is a sophomore majoring in journalism.


33 Comments | Leave a comment

user-pic

Well written article, but I especially liked the title. VIN DIESEL!

user-pic

Hey, Barry HO has been President NOT-George W Bush for 9 months, isn’t that enough?

Perhaps he’s in good company with Yassar and Jimmy and Al, but then they actually did DO something.

user-pic

Neolib Obama must have talked these globaists into a premature orgasim. Time to wake up from the wet dream. They might as well have given the award to Dick Cheney, because I see no difference between the two.

user-pic

who gives a shit about the Nobel prize anyway

user-pic

I can’t believe the Nobel committee actually lowered their standards to give a prize to Obama. What has he done to earn it? He hasn’t accomplished a thing. The Muslim countries don’t want to work with him, western countries don’t think he’s a particularly effective leader and most of the folks who voted for him are starting to have second thoughts. Not that any of the above can rightfully complain, but apart from the ones who voted for McCain, the rest of us saw it coming. For as long as Democrats and Republicans maintain their two-party monopoly on politics, we’ll get more of the same no matter which party’s candidates we vote for. Next election, look to third parties. They’re not necessarily better, but the more competition, the harder they’ll all work to regain our trust and confidence.

user-pic

Looks like another Paultard’s butt hurts a little :(

user-pic

Yes, he didnt deserve it but its not his fault for getting awarded something. Kissinger negotiating a retreat deserved it? i wouldnt give the nobel to much weight

user-pic

He deserves it! He has inspired the whole world. The rest of the world is willing to work with him to ensure peace everywhere.He election was the only presidential election that affected the whorld in a positive way.No other event in history has done that.

user-pic

What? LOL at general ignorance

user-pic

According to Nobel’s will, the Peace Prize should be awarded to the person who: “ during the preceding year […] shall have done the most or the best work for fraternity between nations, for the abolition or reduction of standing armies and for the holding and promotion of peace congresses”

user-pic

“He deserves it! He has inspired the whole world. The rest of the world is willing to work with him to ensure peace everywhere.”

Yeah, Koolaid is known to produce a euphoric effect on the brain. Drink more!

“He election was the only presidential election that affected the whorld in a positive way.No other event in history has done that.”

LEARN TO TYPE, ASSHOLE!!!

user-pic

The first paragraph has five ideas:

1) the similarity between the Obama, MLK Jr, Mohamed Anwar Al-Sadat, and Mother Teresa 2) the accomplishments of MLK Jr. 3) the accomplishments of Mohamed Anwar Al-Sadat 4) the accomplishments of Mother Theresa 5) the (lack of) accomplishments of Obama

Therefore, it should be five paragraphs. Someone, either the writer or the editor, needs to learn how to edit.

Sure, it’s a column, but 150 word paragraphs to start the story are not the way to draw in your readers. And any story of more than 700 words should have more than 7 paragraphs.

user-pic

The first paragraph has five ideas:

1) the similarity between the Obama, MLK Jr, Mohamed Anwar Al-Sadat, and Mother Teresa 2) the accomplishments of MLK Jr. 3) the accomplishments of Mohamed Anwar Al-Sadat 4) the accomplishments of Mother Theresa 5) the (lack of) accomplishments of Obama

Therefore, it should be five paragraphs. Someone, either the writer or the editor, needs to learn how to edit.

Sure, it’s a column, but 150 word paragraphs to start the story are not the way to draw in your readers. And any story of more than 700 words should have more than 7 paragraphs.

user-pic

and a person critiquing style should figure out how to double post, you dumbass noob.

user-pic

I lol’d

user-pic

The Nobel committee can give the prize to anyone they want, despite the opinion of some piss-ant nothing college student. I’m going to start a prize for whiny-ass Americans; you, right-wing media, and the Tea Baggers are on the top of my list. Get over it, get back to work.

user-pic

I don’t think he got the Nobel as a hopeful thing, as in like “We are giving this to him because of what he says he is going to do” — which seems to be the way you’re interpreting it. Maybe I’m wrong but that seems to be what you’re saying.

I think he got the Nobel partly because of the way he is using his power: he is committed to uniting not just Americans but people around the world. This world-view has bothered some conservatives, for example, but it is what makes him worthy of a Nobel; he knows that the best homeland security is to promote peace and solidarity rather than hostility. And, as Andrew Sullivan put it, “He has already done more to heal the open wound between the West and Islam than anyone else on the planet.” He has undoubtedly changed the international climate for the better, and who else could have brought that about on such a scale?

But then there’s another reason why he got it, and I think this is the big reason. A commenter from reddit.com put it nicely: “This is a classic ploy by the Nobel Committee to shame the recipient into changing his behavior. I’ve seen this drama played out many times in my long life — someone who is obviously not a peacenik gets the Prize and feels tremendous pressure to live up to the honor.”

So, contrary to what you said, I don’t think it’s as simple as the Nobel committee awarding him under the hope and assumption that he’s going to do good things down the road; I don’t think it’s a naively preemptive award. What it is is a recognition of the change he’s brought so far; and a tactful means of holding a man who has such potential to positively change things, to a high principle and expectation.

As an American this makes me very happy. Yeah, it’s nice (or maybe not, everyone has their opinion) that he got such a big award. But it’s much nicer to know that, now, in the back of his mind, whenever he is making big decisions, he has to see those in light of being a Nobel peace prize recipient — and I’d like to think that Obama’s decisions will be affected for the better because of it.

user-pic

I agree 100%!

user-pic

I love how all of a sudden the media and the public act like they give a shit who wins this prize. Who won last year? The year before that? I highly doubt anyone could rattle off those names. And finally, it’s not like Obama went to Norway to campaign for the prize. He won, donated the money, and that’s that. Get over it.

user-pic

8:26 AM, the comments about shaming the recipient into being more of a peacenik are really important. But if Obama is convinced by this prize to abandon the people of Afghanistan to civil war and reemerging theocracy, then shame on Obama and shame on the Nobel Committee.

user-pic

It’s a bribe - they want Barry HO to engineer the decline of the USA.

Read this and weep:

Decline Is a Choice The New Liberalism and the end of American ascendancy. by Charles Krauthammer 10/19/2009

http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/017/056lfnpr.asp

Of symbolic but also more concrete importance is the status of the dollar. The social democratic vision necessarily involves huge increases in domestic expenditures, most immediately for expanded health care. The plans currently under consideration will cost in the range of $1 trillion. And once the budget gimmicks are discounted (such as promises of $500 billion cuts in Medicare which will never eventuate), that means hundreds of billions of dollars added to the monstrous budgetary deficits that the Congressional Budget Office projects conservatively at $7 trillion over the next decade.

The effect on the dollar is already being felt and could ultimately lead to a catastrophic collapse and/or hyperinflation. Having control of the world’s reserve currency is an irreplaceable national asset. Yet with every new and growing estimate of the explosion of the national debt, there are more voices calling for replacement of the dollar as the world currency—not just adversaries like Russia and China, Iran and Venezuela, which one would expect, but just last month the head of the World Bank.

user-pic

Haha, quoting a Krauthammer piece as if he’s an impartial observer? Seriously? From The Weekly Standard? Okay, let me just rebuff that with a quote from a recent White House press release, I’m sure you’ll find that equally satisfactory.

user-pic

If you can win a Nobel Peace Prize for being in two different wars and considering sending more troops into one of those, then anyone can win the Nobel. I can’t believe that even people all the way in Europe went along with that whole “Hope and Change” thing. Can we trade the President’s prize for the 2016 Olympics in Chicago?

user-pic

You forgot about the other Peace Prize winners, Yasser Arafat the terrorist and Jimmy Carter the terrorist appeaser.

The Nobel Peace Prize is a leftist ideology prize.

user-pic

FW de Klerk and Nelson Mandela were both co-awarded the prize in 1993, and I wouldn’t quite call de Klerk a leftist.

user-pic

He hits the nail right on the head. The awarding of the prize to President Obama signifies the lack of importance of this previously venerable award

user-pic

I wouldn’t have given it to him either, but all the hand wringing about it wreaks of Republican sour grapes.

user-pic

Reagan frees millions from the Soviet yoke. Bush I frees Kuwait. Bush II frees millions from horrible dictators in Iraq and Afghanistan.

NO PRIZE FOR YOU! Come back when you are a Democrat!

Yeah, I’d be sour too.

user-pic

You have a very rosy opinion of Republican “accomplishments”.

user-pic

I overheard two girls talking about it in a coffee shop on State Street this morning. One girl said “I wish I were in Canada now with all my mom’s relatives. I can’t believe the $hi++y state of affairs and the morons who voted for him, me included.”

While I wouldn’t be so harsh, I can see how many young people who voted for Obama are now disillusioned with his performance and the accolades he doesn’t deserve. Can we do that blue state secession thing now? That sounds like a lot of fun.

user-pic

I wonder if she was awake during the Bush administration? Perhaps growing pubes was more interesting than watching the news for 8 years. Bush did a lot, but everything he did really sucked.

user-pic

Vin Diesel gave a pretty oscar worthy performance in boiler room. Maybe you should have used someone else.

user-pic

Vin Diesel gave a pretty oscar worthy performance in boiler room. Maybe you should have used someone else.

Leave a comment

To comment anonymously or if signed in, leave name and e-mail blank.

Place a shout-out!
Top Classified Ads (view all)

CAMP RANDALL/ENGINEERING: 304 Princeton Ave. 3 bdrm/ bath, or 4 bdrm/3 bath, partially furnished. Free heat and parking, dishwasher, A/C. $1,350-$1,530 or $1,800-$2,030/mo. Available Aug. 15. 608-255-7100.

Place a classified ad

Advertising