Opinion: Guest column

Madison leftists should take cue from moderates

Zach Schuster
Sharing tools:

E-mail this article:




Vote 0 Votes

Back in 2004, after a particularly bad game against the hated Yankees, Red Sox star pitcher Pedro Martinez was asked about his struggles against the Evil Empire. Instead of making excuses, all he could offer was “What can I say? I tip my hat and call the Yankees my daddy.”

It is no secret self-described progressives feel the political success of Barack Obama’s moderate liberal philosophy is somehow fraudulent. In light of this, the butt-whoopings Progressive Dane-backed candidates received in the recent Madison City Council elections are akin to Martinez being owned by the arch-rival Yankees. Madison’s political left can move forward in a myriad of ways, but one of the best would be to cut the excuses and own up to its failures against Obamaism.

The political philosophy of Obamaism can be best defined by a results-based liberal platform and a well-organized and committed field campaign. It is clear Obamaism drives members of Progressive Dane to near insanity because of its moderate platform that puts results above ideology, and the fact moderate liberals are now beating progressives at their own game of grassroots campaigning.

This dynamic was evident in the high-profile City Council races in Districts 2 and 8. Progressive Dane has traditionally enjoyed success in these districts because of its organizational structure and progressive message. However, it’s been said success breeds complacency, and it appears the local left was unprepared for two candidates to make serious challenges in these districts.

Bryon Eagon’s connection to Obamaism is pretty clear, as he was the Wisconsin State Coordinator of Students for Barack Obama. By all accounts, he organized effectively and campaigned extremely hard for the District 8 seat and had a completely competent platform of relevant issues that led my controversy-craving editors to proclaim, “WTF, Bryon?”

His success contrasts with that of Progressive Dane-backed candidate Katrina Flores, who lost in the primary to a political neophyte whose claim to fame at UW will forever be as the political Cookie Monster. In a story published in The Badger Herald last week, Flores partially blamed her defeat on being too busy with other things to run a committed campaign, instead of saying something along the lines of “I half-assed it and was hoping to win using the progressive label.”

While Eagon’s triumph was expected, the true shocker of the Common Council races was Bridget Maniaci’s epic upset over progressive stalwart Brenda Konkel in District 2. Normally a four-term incumbent with a strong record of fighting for progressive issues would seem to be a shoe-in, but in recent years Konkel has cast herself as A-Rod’s arch-enemy to Mayor Dave Cieslewicz’s Red Sox Nation.

Obama’s success can be partly attributed to his promises to put ideological differences aside to actually get policies passed. This desire for action is clearly alive in District 2, as Konkel’s obstructionism on the council provided a contrast to Maniaci’s promises to work with her colleagues to achieve results. Konkel’s rabble-rousing was a dominant narrative of this race, and thus her loss is a clear sign voters of District 2 felt it was time to move on from those tactics.

Konkel and her allies’ response to Maniaci’s upset victory was to primarily blame the city establishment for declaring war on a true principled progressive. Blaming the “establishment” is a bush-league way of owning up to a losing campaign while acting like a sore loser by denying Maniaci the credit she rightfully deserves for a phenomenal campaign. Maniaci’s campaign represents everything the far left despises about Obamaism — a moderate platform not based on antagonizing the mayor and a candidate who organized and campaigned her butt off — and her victory over Konkel is obviously a painful defeat that is going to take progressives a long time to get over.

The recent elections show Obamaism is going to continue to challenge Progressive Dane’s traditional power in local liberal politics. The left can continue to make excuses for its failures, or it can own up to its shortcomings against this new kind of local political campaigning. In short, perhaps it’s best Progressive Dane tip its hat and call Obamaism its daddy.

Zach Schuster (zschuster@wisc.edu) is a graduate student studying water resources engineering and water resources management.


12 Comments | Leave a comment

user-pic

see hears the problem with the far left win: its because people are ready for our Agenda, down with the capitalist pigs! lose: its because people are not ready for out Agenda, evil capitalist pigs!

the amount of cognitive dissonance from the PD/far left is amazing

user-pic

howwwwww dareeeeeeee you question jabba the SZAR!!!!!!!!!!!

user-pic

Shoo-in.

user-pic

The left has an arrogance of its own. They just don’t like to think of it that way. Personally, I’m fed up with both liberals and conservatives. They’ve both taken turns stabbing everyone in the back.

user-pic

This is what happens when you try to sort everyone into just a few categories, Liberal or Conservative. The fact of the matter is that many people (the smart ones) actually decide how they view a particular issue based on that issue and not because the identify themselves as of a particular political ideal.

I identify my self as liberal, but my views on immigration are more conservative then most on the left.

The people that get angry over a politician they voted for not agreeing with them 100% of the time are the same folks that think that if you are a liberal or conservitive then all of your thoughts should align in only a liberal or conservitive way. Thoughtful and deliberative people just don’t think that way.

I for instance was initially very angry that President Obama said that CIA operatives that tortured prisoners would not be prosecuted because they were told it was legal by the DOJ. (Although the Nazi guards on trial at Nuremberg could not use that as a defense). As long as the criminals from the DOJ that told the CIA to go ahead with the torture, I’ll feel as if justice has been served.

user-pic

Obama is fraudulent.

Bagram=Gitmo

look up Bagram. same as Gitmo, just in a different place

user-pic

Im not certain where this was heading, but it appears to be some finger pointing anyways. Madison may appear liberal from outside perspective, but runs with no idealogy other than self preservation. Elected or not, Dane county has more people on the taxpayers payroll than most capital cities of states twice our size. That says it all. Ive been asking leadership to look at itself for along time, but that would require looking past their pension dates and lifetime healthcare benefits. But thats another issue.

user-pic

Without addressing any of the absurdities in this article, numerous PDers backed Obama’s candidacy, including Brenda Konkel’s campaign manager and the PD Election’s chair. PD membership has always been a mix of all sorts of different people on the left. Zach, you really should try to check in with reality before writing. This is a hack piece based on some ridiculous caricatures.

Progressive Dane has always been an organization based on pragmatism and getting things done. It’s things like PD county supervisors pushing for the 911 Center audit and the 1% COLA increase for human services, PD alders trying to prevent the bus fare hike, or pushing for more opportunities for meaningful public involvement at all levels of local government. That why, for example, PD wouldn’t back a candidate against Brian Solomon on the city council because he’s a good progressive, even though he’s not a PD alder.

The amount of cognitive dissonance from the obsessive anti-PD people is astounding.

user-pic

I’d like to weigh in with a couple points: 1. The local angle. Let’s just keep in mind that the actual basic political platforms of Bridget Maniaci and Brenda Konkel were not all that different. What Mayor Dave (who together with the Madison Police Union endorsed evicting Brenda) really objected to was the fact that Alderwoman Konkel wasn’t the kind of suffering, sychophantic suck-up that he prefers. Boss Cieslewicz desires the kind of alderwoman who agrees with the “strong mayor” on nearly every issue rather than standing on principle when she has bona fide objections and concerns. Let’s also remember that the actual electoral results were quite close - Maniaci won by what, 50 votes? Hardly a major mandate! No slur against Bridget, but it’s beginning to look like Cieslewicz insists his alderwomen be young, dumb and subservient.

  1. The national angle. I voted for Obama, for reasons that might seem obvious - consider the alternative! Not to mention the salient issue of the US Supreme Court - can you imagine the kind of nominee McCain would endorse, when Justice Stevens (88 or 89 years old and I’m guessing soon to retire) and Justice Ginsburg leave the bench? Attila the Hun in black robes! But I digress, big time. What’s really important is that one does not have to be a leftist to object to Obama’s recent accomodationism, whether on granting amnesty to CIA torturers, letting the NSA off the hook for illegal wiretapping, or retaining a significant number of very heinous Bush-regime policies generally. I am not necessarily a raving radical because I believe Obama’s deploying thousands more American troops to Afghanistan is worse than a fools errand - it’s a damn lethal and destructive foreign policy blunder. If we can’t learn from the historic ass-whuppings doled out to the Brits in the 19th century and the Soviets 25 years ago, when will we ever learn? And the unmanned aerial drone attacks on defenseless civilians in both Afghanistan and Pakistan are a contemptible, cowardly way to wage a war of aggression on the cheap. These are my genuine convictions, which transcend political labels to a substantial degree. And continuing the Dracula, er, Bush/Cheney administration’s policy of trillion-dollar corporate welfare to the likes of A.I.G. and Goldman Sachs is an outrage that understandably made many registered dems AND repubs see red. Russ Feingold and Herb Kohl both opposed the most recent round of bailouts.

Obama is an intelligent, articulate, relatively reasonable President, but he is all of those things specifically in contrast to the insane, greedy, murderous, scandalously damaging neocons who preceeded him. He is not, and should not be regarded as a sacred cow. Let’s “hold his feet to the flame,” when he is demonstrably WRONG, as he has already been on several notable occasions! Sincerely, Dan A. Goldstein, Madison resident and self-professed political pragmatist.

user-pic

Barry Ho is just a ward heeler from the Chicago Machine, nothing more, nothing less.

Look for Illinois to get BIG money for the next four years, probably eight.

That is all.

Unless they get the 22nd Amendment changed to allow Barry HO to be President for Life, like his new BFF from Venezuela, then it’ll get REAL interesting.

user-pic

nd the unmanned aerial drone attacks on defenseless civilians in both Afghanistan and Pakistan are a contemptible, cowardly way to wage a war of aggression on the cheap.

Cowardly way to wage a war, when your elitist ass is the one being shot at instead of using a drone let’s see how you feel about it then.

user-pic

“unmanned aerial drone attacks on defenseless civilians”

Yeah, they’re all “defenseless civilians” until they start shooting.

When you’re wounded and left on Afghanistan’s plains, And the women come out to cut up what remains, Jest roll to your rifle and blow out your brains An’ go to your Gawd like a soldier.

http://www.everypoet.com/archive/poetry/RudyardKipling/kiplingtheyoungbritish_soldier.htm

Leave a comment

To comment anonymously or if signed in, leave name and e-mail blank.

Place a shout-out!
Top Classified Ads (view all)

SPRING SUBLET: 1 bedroom in 2 bedroom at the Aberdeen. Rent negotiable. Email arkramer@wisc.edu

GENTLE WOMEN...THROUGH the lens of Douglas J. Nesbit, newly released book now available for holiday gifts! www.gentlewomen.us

Place a classified ad

Advertising