Opinion
Madison cannot fix Gaza conflict
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
Also by James Sonneman:
- Madison cannot fix Gaza conflict (January 29, 2009)
- Minnesota faces unenviable dilemma in Senate recount (January 16, 2009)
- Fraternities not entirely to blame for UW's drinking debacle (December 3, 2008)
- Election serves up some real 'change' (November 5, 2008)
- Republican guest will distort Islam (October 15, 2008)
Sharing tools:
E-mail this article:
Words over the recent conflicts and humanitarian crisis in Gaza have been flying across this campus as swiftly as snowballs on Bascom. The pages of this paper have recently been peppered with quotes from Palestinians by Kyle Szarzynski and quotes from Israelis by Jordan Soffer.
The truth is that this is a ridiculously complicated situation that nobody outside of the two territories can perhaps comprehend completely — no one comes back from a Campus Antiwar Network meeting or a Birthright trip with such intricate knowledge of what exactly is going on in the Holy Land.
Soffer diplomatically pleads “to the media, to governments around the world, and to every student on this campus to help find that common ground.” It is a step in the right direction, but a step several years behind the times. To imply that common ground doesn’t exist already does a severe injustice to the millions on both sides who peacefully seek a two-state solution.
The two-state solution has the highest support among both peoples. Most Palestinians acknowledge that Israelis must have a state (they have put down their roots as deeply as the English in Northern Ireland). On the other hand, most Israelis say the same for the Palestinians, who cannot just fuck off to a place that they don’t come from.
Carrying out the solution is not easy, however. As Thomas Friedman eloquently put it in the New York Times, “Hamas is busy making (it) inconceivable, while (Israeli) settlers have steadily worked to make it impossible.” A great schlep is being done to both Israelis and Palestinians by those who benefit from hostilities between the peoples. While Hamas gains notoriety, and distance from Fatah, by firing rockets in the vicinity of civilians, some overzealous Israelis continue to settle in agreed upon Palestinian territory, destroying Palestinian homes in the process. The generals on both sides, meanwhile, get to keep their jobs and build their budgets.
The recent Israeli incursion was simply asinine if its goal was to eventually achieve peace. What has been achieved since December when the crisis began? The military campaign certainly did nothing to bring elements of Hamas back into the fold of Fatah and establish peace between the Palestinians themselves — an important element in the creation of Palestinian autonomy and independence. A score of people are dead, some were thugs, many were innocent women and children, and the peace process has taken a further step back.
Hamas rockets are inexcusable but cannot be an excuse for the intensity of Israel’s reaction. By funneling its scarce resources into such relatively useless rockets while its people suffered tremendously under a crippling economic blockade, Hamas was greatly undermining its legitimacy in Gaza. Hamas was arguably on the road to destroying itself from within, had the Israeli government played the waiting game more prudently. Admittedly, it is difficult to win an upcoming election — Feb. 10 — when the government does nothing in response to a few crude rocket attacks.
In Madison, we can debate about the issue in the papers all we want and, seemingly, not much difference will be made. I implore you — consume information, read books with five-star Amazon ratings, watch movies such as “Paradise Now” or “Live from Bethlehem” — an excellent documentary on Palestinian media produced by University of Wisconsin students. As Amira Hanania said, we are “the future leaders of America and in politics nothing is very far from America. (We) have a responsibility to make our country do whatever it can to make the lives of Palestinians, Israelis and all people throughout the world as good and peaceful as possible.” Or at least, as the Flight of the Concords say, “Just think about it. (falsetto) Think, think about it.”
James Sonneman (sonneman@wisc.edu) is a senior majoring in political science.
6 Comments | Leave a comment
Leave a comment
Herald Blogs
The Beat Goes On
Fans of Waits will not be disappointed
Muckrakers
Report: Barrett to make decision by the end of the week
Extra Points
Top Classified Ads (view all)
SPRING SUBLET: 1 bedroom in 2 bedroom at the Aberdeen. Rent negotiable. Email arkramer@wisc.edu
GENTLE WOMEN...THROUGH the lens of Douglas J. Nesbit, newly released book now available for holiday gifts! www.gentlewomen.us
IP hash: b50b83d6
James, it’s obvious you side with the Palestinians. Israel didn’t invade Gaza to achieve peace, they invaded to subdue Hamas. The only mistake Israel made is that they didn’t finish Hamas off completely.
By the way, did you know that 1) the UN was secretly allowing Hamas to use their ambulances to transport Hamas fighters around Gaza and 2) Iran is trying to smuggle weapons into Gaza by sea?
IP hash: 6a10a8ed
Right! So Leftists hand-wringers should sit down, pour themselves a nice cup of STFU… and let IDF soldiers do their job.
For a more complete illustration of the conflict history, go here; http://www.terrorismawareness.org/what-really-happened/
IP hash: e416bdc6
Great article James.
IP hash: 70642d0d
“Hamas rockets are inexcusable but cannot be an excuse for the intensity of Israel’s reaction.”
Yeah, Israel should just shoot the same number of crude, unguilded rockets into the civilian areas of Gaza. Would that be excusable?
IP hash: 4a183f47
James, you’re going to piss off all the east coast jews in madison.
IP hash: abd65960
Seamus, did you remember to pay tommy tiernan his 1%?