Opinion: Guest column
American tragedy abroad extends beyond Iraq borders
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
Also by Jonah Zinn:
- American tragedy abroad extends beyond Iraq borders (November 12, 2008)
Sharing tools:
E-mail this article:
Many people have come to the conclusion that the war in Iraq is unjustified because of the obvious absence of WMDs and the lack of evidence that al-Qaida is linked to Iraq. But what about the war in Afghanistan? Up to this point it has earned the title of “the Good War;” the war that is actually fighting terrorism and the Taliban head-on. However, as is the case with Iraq, few actually know how horrendous the situation in Afghanistan has become and how the $100 million of American taxpayer money is really being spent every day.
With the election of Barack Obama as our 44th president, the focus of our military foreign policy will undoubtedly shift toward the war in Afghanistan. Now more than ever it is imperative for the American people to learn the real facts about the war. As more and more Americans are killed in the name of the War on Terror, it is the right of the American citizens to know what our brothers, sisters, sons, daughters, parents and friends are really dying for.
So here are the facts: The unemployment rate in Afghanistan as of 2005 reached upwards of 45 percent. However, recent estimates suggest unemployment as high as 80 percent in some areas. Since there is such a lack of work in the severely underdeveloped Afghan economy, more than half the country’s GDP is devoted to opium production. And according to Afghan officials, this winter may kill as much as 80 percent of the population in some northern provinces due to a shortage of food that has been compounded by a massive drought. The food shortage is so critical in some places that Afghan parents have been driven to sell their children in order to survive. Others have had no alternative source of nourishment besides eating grass. While one might hope that the American forces have been struggling to combat this horrendous spike in hunger and unemployment, of the $100 million a day being spent in Afghanistan, only $5 million is devoted toward humanitarian aid, while a whopping $40 million returns to donor countries in the form of corporate profits.
Proponents of the war argue we have established a functioning Afghan government and that the Taliban is on the run. Both these claims are false. The established Hamid Karzai government is incapable, weak and corrupt. It provides little to no social services and expends all its efforts trying to hold itself together. According to a 2008 U.S. intelligence report, only about 30 percent of Afghanistan is controlled by the national government. The rest is ruled by local tribal leaders and warlords who are not affected by the jurisdiction of Karzai’s government. Karzai is also notoriously corrupt, pardoning dangerous criminals who have committed such crimes as bayonet raping a woman and turning a blind eye to his brother, one of the top heroin lords in the country.
As to the fight against the Taliban, al-Qaida has resurged as far as Kabul, the capital, and proves to be an attractive alternative to the American forces. In 2007, U.S. and NATO forces surged in Afghanistan, increasing troop levels by 45 percent. However, this surge also saw a 50 percent increase in violence as well as a decline in jobs, reconstruction and security. The decline in jobs, food and hope pushes Afghanis into the arms of the Taliban, which can offer a salary and the promise of expelling the invading Americans from Afghanistan.
With a large troop surge expected to occur in Afghanistan under Obama, it is important that we as the American public are truly aware of the consequences of such a surge to the American troops as well as to the Afghan population. Join the Campus Antiwar Network this Thursday at 6:30 (location found in TITU) to learn the real facts about the war in Afghanistan and to start making a difference.
Jonah Zinn (jzinn@wisc.edu) is a member of the Campus Anti-War Network.
6 Comments | Leave a comment
Leave a comment
Herald Blogs
The Beat Goes On
Fans of Waits will not be disappointed
Muckrakers
Report: Barrett to make decision by the end of the week
Extra Points
Top Classified Ads (view all)
SPRING SUBLET: 1 bedroom in 2 bedroom at the Aberdeen. Rent negotiable. Email arkramer@wisc.edu
GENTLE WOMEN...THROUGH the lens of Douglas J. Nesbit, newly released book now available for holiday gifts! www.gentlewomen.us
IP hash: 55e51fbd
Oh so this whole article was just a commercial of sorts brought to you by “your friendly Campus Anti-War Hippies”. I guess since things in Iraq have slowed you have to find other reasons to justify your existence? How’s about the wars in the Congo or is it just American Wars your against?
Anyways glad to see that you may have a chance to visit Afghanistan since Obama is a firm proponent of National Service at some level.
IP hash: b6355896
Sigh another piece by the Campus Antiwar Network. I see that you are on the right track but Jonah where is the agency of the Afghan people in your article? They are made to be objects that can be separated into two categories 1. Victims 2. Oppressors. When writing an article or even speaking about anything outside of your borders remember the people you are speaking about are people not just objects. Your job is not to “save them” by ending the war, your job is to use your American privilege in a constructive manor so that any person outside the US can help themselves. Because the problem is not that the Afghans need our help, the problem is that we need to stop speaking, acting, and deciding for them.
IP hash: d59c084e
Bring ALL the troops home, including Germany, Japan, Korea, etc.
Put them on the borders. Beef up the Navy and Coast Guard.
Let the world know any attack on the USA will result in a large molten hole in the ground somewhere, say Mecca if there is any repeat of 9-11.
IP hash: dc98e4fb
“…while a whopping $40 million returns to donor countries in the form of corporate profits.” Sources? Without them, you’re just some guy making outlandish claims.
IP hash: 8d1a0220
Jonah is hottttt
IP hash: 84257181
Jonah im your brother. Hi