Opinion: Editorial
Better dead than RED
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
Also by Badger Herald Editorial Board:
- The Invisible Man Award: Wyndham Manning (May 7, 2009)
- The People's Choice Award: Jacqueline Hitchon et. al (May 7, 2009)
- The Lifetime Achievement Award: ASM (May 7, 2009)
- Honest representation (May 5, 2009)
- Junger for ASM Chair (May 5, 2009)
Sharing tools:
E-mail this article:
The University of Wisconsin-Madison could use a little help in a few key areas. State funding for professor salaries would be useful, financial aid is certainly lagging, and it would be nice if someone could give the folks over at Associated Students of Madison a helping hand with that whole “Student Government” thing.
However, one could hardly argue we suffer from a dearth of student publications on campus. In addition to the two student newspapers, there is a music-oriented quarterly, a humanities-oriented quarterly, the occasional rogue satire newspaper and a per-semester cultural arts magazine published in conjunction with the journalism school. Add in the Wisconsin State Journal, Isthmus, Onion and Capital Times, and it’s obvious there is no lack of reading material on this campus.
But, apparently, you haven’t read anything “until you’ve read RED.”
Yeah, we thought it was a typo too.
On Monday, the campus racks held the promise of a new student periodical called RED Magazine, an 80-page glossy wonder purporting to cover “everything college.”
For those who’ve not had a chance to experience “everything college” or pick up this comprehensive student summary, here’s what it consists of:
- An analysis of the sconnie-coastie divide, which seems to affirm the stereotypes it attempts to dismiss — including a bizarre conception of the “sconnie” stereotype, which looks like a homeless Kim Basinger.
- A front-page feature on students who “do more than just spend their days in class and nights in bars” — which assumes people don’t know who Allan Evridge is.
- A romance column that assumes courtship was only thrown into nerve-wracking complications with the invention of text messaging.
- A position run-down of the presidential candidates that includes embryonic stem cell research under “civil rights” and has a rare moment of candor by admitting all candidate positions are “subject to change.”
RED also comes with bonus materials such as countless typos, garish design and other generic articles that encapsulate the idea of “college.”
But our ultimate dissatisfaction is not borne out of their choice of content. Rather, it’s the fact that our chancellor’s office actually funded this project. On the inside cover of RED, Casey Nagy, special assistant to the chancellor, is quoted as saying, “You’ve created a wonderful concept; it deserves a chance.” This is the same chancellor’s office, remember, that was run at the time by John Wiley, who was last seen telling us how dire the university’s financial situation was in Madison Magazine.
Sure, RED deserves a chance — in the free market. Subsidizing an unproven publication that fills no niche so they can produce 14,000 issues doesn’t give them a chance; it gives them crutches.
Perhaps RED will be able to sustain itself on advertising revenue, and this magazine is just a test run. But whether we need — or want — a magazine like this should be decided by consumers and advertisers, not the chancellor’s office.
12 Comments | Leave a comment
Leave a comment
Herald Blogs
The Beat Goes On
Muckrakers
President’s Visit Marked a Speech to One of the Last Groups Not Critical of Him
Extra Points
Top Classified Ads (view all)
HOUSES FOR Fall 2010. All houses are on W Dayton or N Bassett. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, or 8 bedrooms. All have parking. madisoncampusrentals.com
“However, one could hardly argue we suffer from a dearth of student publications on campus. In addition to the two student newspapers, there is a music-oriented quarterly, a humanities-oriented quarterly, the occasional rogue satire newspaper and a per-semester cultural arts magazine published in conjunction with the journalism school. Add in the Wisconsin State Journal, Isthmus, Onion and Capital Times, and it’s obvious there is no lack of reading material on this campus.”
BLOGS
I love the exponential increase in sarcasm used by Herald Ed board pieces
yeah, blogs, and Charles Dickens too.
the socialist badger herald advocating for the free market to decide? wtf???
Is sarcasm the only way of expressing opinions these days?
hmmm sounds like the badger herald feels a little threatened…
a little?
this magazine was funded by a special grant specific for student projects like this. I loved the magazine, Keep em’ coming.
mean spirited, petty, pick on someone your own size!
I would have to say that this article was extremely distasteful and petty. It does not reflect well on where the editorial board is choosing to direct its attention. It was a student project and it remains to be a great accomplishment. This article has no purpose but to express childish feelings of jealousy.
I agree with all of the above comments. A lot of time, hard work, and dedication was put into this magazine by dozens of people and the Badger Herald could show a bit of support and respect for the colleagues in their field. Obviously they’re threatened and probably worried because all of campus was reading this magazine, front to back, and they will probably do so every time it comes out, not just on Wednesdays…
It seems odd for an entire editorial board to take potshots at a potential rival for readership. Red seems like a good learning opportunity for student writers who do not wish to establish fascist liberal credentials (which seems like a prerequisite to writing for the Badger Herald?).