Opinion
Irrational fears fuel crime focus
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
Also by Kyle Szarzynski:
- District 2 needs Brenda Konkel (April 1, 2009)
- Union's fraud not going unnoticed by students (March 12, 2009)
- Marijuana laws ridiculous, impractical (March 5, 2009)
- Constitution bad for orgs (February 19, 2009)
- Both sides have point in abortion debate (February 5, 2009)
Sharing tools:
E-mail this article:
The crime scare that has compressed the University of Wisconsin community over the last year or two seems to have squeezed out the potential for a rational discussion of campus safety, allowing the fear-mongers and panic-stricken to have their way with student opinion. Now that an alleged murderer may (or may not) be living somewhere near the State Street area — a community of tens of thousands of people — many have decided the appropriate response should be hysteria.
Crime happens — that’s obvious enough. But the current climate masks the fact that Madison remains one of the safest cities of its size in the country. Indeed, the statistics show that, if anything, we’re safer now than in previous years.
According to the most recent Madison Police Department report, violent crime witnessed a significant decrease last year in the downtown area. These crimes — which include murder, rape, aggravated assault and robbery — dropped from 253 in 2006 to 178 in 2007 in the Central District.
It is true that, according to the same report, burglaries increased by 26 percent last year. This is reflective of a statewide and regional trend and likely related to the economic downturn. Most of the targets were businesses, not the homes of students or other residents.
Madison is always ranked as one of the top places to live in the country, largely due to its cultural attractions and high standard of life. The latter — caused by low unemployment, a high minimum wage and relatively generous social services — has reduced the primary cause of crime: human want. Low poverty has made Madison a bastion of low crime.
And yet, many students don’t feel safe. Blame for this irrationality can be spread around in a few places, including the significant change in demographic circumstances that, for many, accompany moving to Madison. As safe as the city is, the mostly middle-class student body comes from relatively privileged and homogeneous communities where serious crime is almost nonexistent. It may be unsavory to point out, but many are susceptible to primitive types of fear directed at populations usually not seen in the affluent suburb.
The state makes it easy for people to feel afraid too. Be it the fraudulent national security threats trumpeted by all three major presidential candidates or the frivolous screaming about the drug trade, our own government — theoretically responsible for making us feel more secure — serves as a mouthpiece for the omnipresent boogeyman.
But fault mostly resides with the local media, and the campus portion of which is particularly guilty. The rare assault or mugging on campus is often greeted with hyperbolic frustration and demands for a bolstered police apparatus. Last year, The Daily Cardinal even ran a three-day, front page feature entitled “Are You Safe?” The implied answer was that, surprisingly enough, we are not. Sensationalism sells.
The anxiety has gotten to the point that local politicians must either pander to the delirium or face criticism from the press, as the current District 5 supervisor knows all too well.
Conor O’Hagan, one of the two candidates running as a replacement, cites campus safety, apparently under siege from mysterious dark forces, as his No. 1 priority. Aside from confirming the absurd depths to which this issue has descended, Mr. O’Hagan’s position shows how scare-mongering can be an effective political tool, especially when an issue-based platform is conspicuously absent.
With that said, everyone has the right to be safe. Crime, even when rare, must be addressed. The solution, however, is not to put more cops on the street — the city just added an unprecedented 30 new officers in February. The cost for hiring more police officers is astronomical in the near-term, while the long-term required funds leech off of more intelligent proposals and programs.
But more importantly, there is little evidence that increased police presence has any effect on curbing crime. Most poor communities, ever weary of police brutality and intrusion, aren’t exactly up-in-arms over the supposed lack of law enforcement, even though it is only their neighborhoods that face a real crime problem in this city. Ald. Brian Solomon, District 10, representative of the low-income Allied Drive, notes on his blog, “When I ask my constituents what will help in their community, not a one mentions an increase in the number of police.”
If the correlation between crime and destitution is a strong one, it would make sense to direct resources toward homelessness prevention, after-school programs, job training, welfare and other social services. These types of measures will not only relieve the financial strain on a criminal justice system that now imprisons one in 100 adults but also address the fact that both the perpetrators and recipients of crime can be victims. Militarizing Madison may offer some immediate psychological relief but is detrimental to the interests of marginalized groups and ultimately ineffective.
In the meantime, crime isn’t going away in a society like ours. But at least we live in a part of the country where it’s rare enough that — contrary to the feverish musings of some quarters — it really is safe to walk home at night all by yourself.
Kyle Szarzynski (kszarzynski@badgerherald.com) is a senior majoring in history and Spanish.
10 Comments | Leave a comment
Leave a comment
Herald Blogs
The Beat Goes On
Brother Ali makes an ‘Exclusive’ stop
Muckrakers
Report: Barrett to make decision by the end of the week
Extra Points
Top Classified Ads (view all)
HOUSES FOR Fall 2010. All houses are on W Dayton or N Bassett. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, or 8 bedrooms. All have parking. madisoncampusrentals.com
” a community of tens of thousands of people — many have decided the appropriate response should be hysteria.”
That’s not true.
And attacking Conor O’Hagan in a last minute editorial for the Progressive Dane candidate.
Sounds like a trick we’ve seen before.
Kyle, I thank you for telling me that it’s safe to walk around alone at night. Of course, since a friend got mugged half a block from my door, and another got chased down Library Mall, I might have to disagree.
“dark forces”
so Conor O’Hagan is a racist????????????????? what the hell.
I’m a female on campus and quite frankly, the amount of violence I see every weekend night on State Street is enough to keep my scared. You are far too insensitive. If you were a woman, you would think differently.
You must not live downtown It is NOT safe to walk around downtown after midnight, particularly if you are alone/intoxicated/female.
Crime has gone from negligible to perceptible, Kyle. Just because this isn’t Baltimore doesn’t mean it’s not a problem.
Wow. Cheap plays from the far left. I thought Manning would have a little more class.
The Manning campaign, unless released tonight, has said nothing about crime. Or anything directly relating to campus safety. Or any real issues facing students. Manning wants more music/cultural events - then his cronies can get more gigs in the Madison area. Manning is a senior with a degree in environmental studies and communications, yet his platform is poor on the environment and campaign material screams “I don’t know what I am doing!” Kumar had policies. Woods and Judge knew the issues. Manning and O’Hagan do not.
At the very least, Conor has time to learn while Manning and use tantalizing speech such as “scare-mongering.” Kyle, what scares me is how ridiculous our campus representation will appear next fall.
At least we have Judge.
4:10—
A lot of people know someone who has been robbed or attacked, but the actual number of people who find themselves in such a situation is fairly low. If you go out in the middle of the night, show the same level of precaution you would in any other city. Madison is a big city now, and as a result we have crime. Just be smart and you’ll be fine. But seriously, compared to Milwaukee, or Los Angeles, or Durham, crime here is very low.
“crime isn’t going away in a society like ours”
Once we reach the Socialist Nirvana only the State will be able to steal and murder.
I think the city is pretty safe in relation to other cities. I’ve seen a stabbing scene and barfights and all that, but I feel like a lot of it is just stupid drunk boys or people on acid beating each other up over egos. If you walk around with a couple friends at night and don’t bother too many people, you should be fine. I am a girl and I haven’t been phyically bothered or harmed by too many creepos… just mostly get verbally hit on by them and have to make up excuses to get away.