Opinion

UW lacks traction on snow transport

This weather sucks. I am over the snow, the cold and, most of all, the everyday struggle to walk to class by climbing massive snow piles and skating across the glaciers that used to be sidewalks. We have all experienced the massive slush lakes that appear at almost every intersection, promising to soak our boots all the way through.

But what if you could not jump over the obstacle? What if, instead of two legs, you depended upon two wheels to get from class to class? The inconvenience of a puddle could turn into an extensive detour.

According to Hannah Buck, diversity chair of the Associated Students of Madison, �it can take some students [with mobility impairments] up to two hours to make a 15-minute trip because they have to alter their routes due to poorly cleared sidewalks.�

It is hard to fathom how a 15-minute trip could suddenly transform into a two-hour ordeal, but, as you walk to class today, look at the sidewalks, especially the crosswalks and intersections. Could a wheelchair plow through the trenches created by the pedestrian traffic? Would someone have to attempt to cross elsewhere? Probably.

Although the University of Wisconsin Physical Plant offers a snow-removal service for those with mobility impairments, I have yet to see many clear sidewalks. According to Physical Plant Central Answering and Response, a person may �request that a pedestrian route be cleared of snow and ice in order to facilitate movement from one building to another.� However, there are several restrictions. The service is not available on weekends or holidays. Last time I checked, it can still snow on Saturdays, Sundays or Christmas. The service that supposedly aids those with mobility impairments does not offer consistent assistance, regardless of changes in weather conditions.

If a physically disabled person cannot use the campus� sidewalks, Madison offers an alternative.

Madison Metro offers paratransit service as an accommodation for those with mobility handicaps. Although this service is offered at no charge to UW students, it is laden with restrictions.

A student must complete and submit an application for the paratransit service. In the process of filling out this application, he or she must determine the category of service to which he or she belongs.

According to City of Madison Eligibility Standards, a person classified as a Category 1 is �any individual with a disability, who is unable to board, ride or disembark from any accessible vehicle on a fixed-route system without the assistance of another individual.�

A Category 2 person, on the other hand, is an individual who utilizes a wheelchair for mobility but can board any vehicle with limited assistance. A person within Category 2 is unlikely to receive a permit for paratransit service because he or she can �easily� board a regular Metro bus. What if it becomes impossible for a person in a wheelchair to reach a Metro bus stop or what if a bus is packed? Although paratransit does allow those within

Category 2 to apply for temporary access to the service, this does not solve the problem.   

The city of Madison has disregarded the needs of an important demographic. If the snow-clearing and paratransit services are not available in all circumstances, what are these students, faculty members, staff and citizens of Madison to do?

A student should not feel abandoned by the university due to his or her mobility constraints. It is time that the university invested in its students. In order to create a more diverse campus, Madison and the university must deliver on its services, especially those which affect the day-to-day lives of those on campus.

Hannah Karns (hkarns@wisc.edu) is a sophomore majoring in political science and international studies.

Have a thought? We welcome your input, but please be polite and stay on topic wherever possible. Your comment may be deleted if it is inappropriately off topic or promotional or if it is unnecessarily rude or contains personal attacks. We may delete comments for other reasons as well. Just keep it simple and focus on your points as respectfully as possible.

We allow and encourage comments employing satire, wit and irony to make points. Do not flag comments just because you disagree. Flagged comments will be immunized from further flagging unless they stray far from the guidelines and do not add to the discussion. Before flagging a comment you think is offensive, consider your time might be better spent rebutting it than censoring it.

blog comments powered by Disqus

12 older comments

user-pic

wheel chairs have four wheels?

user-pic

If you are in a wheel chair, it will be next to impossible to get around this winter. Sorry. Life isn’t fair, and I am sure the people with disabilities understand this more than anyone.

user-pic

How many more irrelevant, unimportant articles will the Badger Herald publish when there are so many real, pressing issues out there?

user-pic

Yes, 7:56. Two large wheels to provide thrust from being spun by the wheelchair bound, and two smaller wheels behind the foot platform to assist in turning and direction.

user-pic

11:10am: How is this irrelevant or not a real issue? Just because you probably aren’t disabled, doesn’t mean that this issue lacks importance. I’d like to see you get around on crutches after breaking your leg—-possibly caused by a fall due to lack of proper winter maintenance. One could argue that the lack of ability to traverse this campus while being disabled is a matter of discrimination. I think you’re forgetting a little thing called the ADA. Snow removal is a joke on this campus, even for the able-bodied student.

user-pic

“How many more irrelevant, unimportant articles will the Badger Herald publish when there are so many real, pressing issues out there?”

That depends on how many articles you write about how unfair it is that you can’t spray sunshine and lollipops out your ass.

user-pic

12:30, that’s 4 wheels. Am I missing something?

user-pic

Because nothing “real” or “pressing” happens in Madison. We are in Wisconsin, people.

user-pic

11:10-

Have you no soul? No compassion for your fellow student/citizen/human being? This is an issue. What effects some, effects all. Please be more considerate.

user-pic

I’ve been on crutches for 3 months with no weight bearing on my left leg because of a broken pelvis. It’s hard enough trying to get around without getting hurt, especially on the hills. I can’t imagine what it would be like to be in a wheelchair. I have to get up 3 hours earlier than I used to, so I can leave my apartment an hour before my class starts just to get to a bus stop a 1/2 mile away to HOPEFULLY catch a bus that would get me to my class on time. Even with the bureaucratic swamp you have to wade through just to get some assistance, you think at least one sidewalk would be cleared. It’s hard to walk with 2 legs on a hill covered in 2 inches of pure ice, it gets exponentially harder as you lose more and more mobility because the university doesn’t take care of their pathways. Why does Madison’s 48-hour policy not apply to UW? It’s been weeks since I’ve seen concrete on the sidewalk, and once you get to businesses on the borders of the university, sidewalks are free and clear. The university is almost begging for a lawsuit by someone who is injured due to the inability of the university to maintain campus grounds.

user-pic

It would be interesting to hear what shape the sidewalks are in at UW-Whitewater, since that’s where UW “recommends” that mobility-impaired students be sent…

user-pic

The Physical Plant disabled accommodation snow removal service is great in theory, except that they close at 4:30pm, and if they haven’t called you back by then (because you had to leave a message), they aren’t going to. Oh, and you have to meet them at the location that needs clearing. Great, people in wheelchairs waiting out in the cold (or stuck in a snow-covered sidewalk). Great idea. NOT.

Donate