I’m not going to spend this little space describing how I feel about Ann Coulter. You wouldn’t be able to print most of it. My goal is merely to point out where Ms. Coulter and UW freshman Heidi Voss ("Ann Coulter: A great American," Oct. 17) have been factually incorrect in their statements over the past week. First, Ms. Coulter’s belief that Christians view themselves as perfected Jews is simply historically illogical. Very few Christians came from Jews. The vast majority of Christians were converted from other groups, which are collectively known, for the most part, as “barbarians.” Ms. Coulter’s and Ms. Voss’ ancestors were never Jewish. So whatever logic makes Christians “perfected Jews” is beyond me. Second, Ms. Coulter’s statement that the United States would be better off if Jews converted to Christianity: Even excluding the Holocaust, this shows extreme historical ignorance. Jews have a 2,000-year history of people either trying to kill us because we’re Jewish (the pogroms) or trying to convert us (the Spanish Inquisition). So when someone says that the U.S. would be better off if we were no longer Jewish, we don’t think of it as a courageous political statement. It’s more along the lines of hate speech. Ms. Coulter’s statement that Christians tolerate Jews but the U.S. would be better off if we all converted to Christianity is not that different from saying that you respect blacks, Asians and Latinos, but think the U.S. would be better off if they moved back to Africa, Asia and Latin America. Third, Ms. Voss’ beliefs that Jews wish Christians were Jews is just wrong. It is difficult to convert to Judaism. You have to take months, if not years, of lessons. If you aren’t circumcised and are male, you need to be. We don’t encourage conversion in any form, except in the case of a Jew marrying a Christian. Honestly, we don’t care what Christians, Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists or anyone else does. We just don’t want you to try to convert us by consistently telling us why we’re wrong. We don’t need to be saved; we’re doing just fine, thanks. And we wouldn’t mind if we didn’t have to hear about Christmas until the day after Thanksgiving. Jews are particularly concerned when people make statements like Ms. Coulter made, even if they are made through stupidity or ignorance instead of malice. We know a bit too well what stupidity and ignorance can lead to. Noah Eisner UW alumnus, 2004, history firstname.lastname@example.org
Coulter wrong on Jews
By Letters to the Editor
Thursday, October 18, 2007 12:00 a.m.
Updated Friday, October 19, 2007 1:00:45 a.m.
Have a thought? We welcome your input, but please be polite and stay on topic wherever possible. Your comment may be deleted if it is inappropriately off topic or promotional or if it is unnecessarily rude or contains personal attacks. We may delete comments for other reasons as well. Just keep it simple and focus on your points as respectfully as possible.
We allow and encourage comments employing satire, wit and irony to make points. Do not flag comments just because you disagree. Flagged comments will be immunized from further flagging unless they stray far from the guidelines and do not add to the discussion. Before flagging a comment you think is offensive, consider your time might be better spent rebutting it than censoring it.
Place your classified ad online and have it show up here. Your ad will hit thousands of viewers a day!
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
- Ann Coulter: A great American (October 17, 2007)
- Sudoku rating offends Jews (October 15, 2007)
- Cartoon anti-Semitic (February 15, 2008)
- Reason, reason, reason, insanity (November 14, 2008)
- Horn misguided on his views of Israel, Taglit-Birthright trips (February 25, 2010)
Also by Letters to the Editor:
- Letter of support from the School of Library and Information Studies (February 25, 2011)
- An open letter to Scott Walker from UW-Madison faculty (February 21, 2011)
- College Republicans dispute ASM e-mail (February 16, 2011)
- Wisconsin Idea corrupted by WID privatization move (December 8, 2010)
- The ethical dilemma of Rose Bowl ticket buyers (December 8, 2010)