OPINION & EDITORIAL
Public bickering demeans tragedy
Looking for a print version?
Simply choose ‘Print’ on your computer and a printer-friendly document will be generated.
Also by Casey Hoff:
- State should allow cabbies to carry (November 22, 2005)
- Don't pass go, don't collect $200 (April 18, 2005)
- Lawmakers twist Avery case for political, personal ends (November 29, 2005)
- Left-wing, right-wing out of bounds with war rhetoric (April 25, 2005)
- Residents, police need to work together (December 6, 2005)
Related Stories:
- Wisconsin's helping hands (September 7, 2005)
- 9/11 anniversary calls for goodwill (September 11, 2006)
- Wisconsin students extend helping hand (September 20, 2005)
- Help for hurricane victims stuck in Iraq (September 15, 2005)
- U.S. government not entirely blameless (September 12, 2001)
by Casey Hoff
Tuesday, September 13, 2005
Just like in the aftermath of the Sept. 11 tragedy four short years ago, the generosity of Madisonians and millions of others throughout the United States has been nothing short of incredible and overwhelming. Private donations alone have nearly topped $700 million.
Madisonians have opened up their homes, schools, wallets, and hearts to Katrina victims. The University of Wisconsin Board of Regents has responded by enrolling and pushing to waive tuition fees for displaced residents of New Orleans sent to the UW System. Madison Public Schools are also enrolling evacuees. Residential areas on Allied Drive have coordinated an effort to bring New Orleans families up to Madison to live in newly refurbished apartments.
One Madisonian named David Worzala made his driveway available for parking on Badger football Saturday, charging a fee of $25, and donating all of the proceeds to hurricane relief efforts. There have been countless charity benefits, blood drives, telethons, and so much more in our own community. The people of this country overwhelmingly understand that blame and accountability will and should come later, but that now is the time to unite as one and help.
Still, there are ideologues from both political extremes that are already engaged in an attempt to politicize what will be known as one of America's greatest tragedies before we even have a body count.
Kanye West blamed the president by blurting out, "George Bush doesn't care about black people" on NBC's "Concert for Hurricane Relief" last weekend. Kanye West was, not surprisingly, acting selfishly. He was too angry to care about those who are starving and dying in the streets because he needed to get his own anger off of his chest, even if his divisive rhetoric cost those affected by the hurricane millions of dollars in relief money and supplies.
Former wrestling coach turned Republican House Speaker Dennis Hastert has already declared, "It makes no sense to spend billions of dollars to rebuild a city that's seven feet under sea level." Hastert is too pessimistic to understand that it is uniquely American to take risks and rebuild our cities after they undergo disasters. It has happened many times throughout this country's history, including in 1871 after the Chicago fire, in 1906 after the San Francisco earthquake, or in 2001 after the Sept. 11 tragedy in New York City. New Orleans has survived other tragedies such as the Napoleonic Wars and the British invasion of 1812. But, for Dennis Hastert, he seems more concerned about what insurance companies will have to pay out if another hurricane hits the region in the future. How compassionate and un-American of you, Denny.
Other comments run the gamut from far-right wingers such as Dr. Brooks Mick of The Conservative Voice, blaming "liberal left-wing social policies" for the devastation. Far-left columnist Alexander Cockburn apparently blames the American people, stating "Katrina the aftermath is payback time for decades of stupidity, greed, pillage, and racism."
People who are politicizing this tragedy so early on must keep this in mind: Not ONE person whose life has been devastated by this Hurricane cares at all about the finger-pointing and bickering from both extreme political sides, left or right. People who are calling George Bush a racist or saying that New Orleans shouldn't be rebuilt because they are worried about their tax dollars are showing that they care more about politicizing this awful tragedy than helping out.
In addition, people who are using this opportunity to blame liberal social policies or take a figurative piss on the institutions of our country are adding nothing to its future, its greatness, or the rebuilding effort.
It is time for people to take the focus off of government. George Bush and Bill Clinton are not going to be the ones that will prevail in this tragedy. It is the people of this country who will be the real heroes of this relief effort. It is the people who always band together in chaotic situations such as this. The average Americans are the ones who are helping, whether it be by their generous donations to public and private charities, by their direct assistance in the relief effort, or by opening up their own homes, schools, and hearts to those in need.
Don't be one of those who finger-points in the immediate aftermath of this tragedy. If you are, just keep in mind that history will not judge you harshly; rather, it will not judge you at all. History will remember those in this wonderful country who banded together and put their sentiments into action. It will reflect on those who moved forward to help, rather than those who looked behind to blame. I am confident, however, that the American people will prevail, as they always do in times of crisis.
Anonymous (September 13, 2005 @ 3:13am):
They gave this guy a column again?
And here I thought that progress had been made...
worst.columnist.ever.
Anonymous (September 13, 2005 @ 6:08am):
Good column Casey! Good job putting a local face and story on a large national issue. You're one of the few worth reading in this paper these days. Of course, you'll probably get a lot of flack for not towing the "progressive" line in this city, but that means you're right on target.
Anonymous (September 13, 2005 @ 9:11am):
"Taking the focus off of government" makes less sense if you realize that we are completely unprepared to deal with a terrorist attack that cripples a city in the way that Katrina crippled New Orleans. Mr. Hoff can hold hands and sing kumbaya; I'd rather the public pushes all levels of government into better preparedness. What was the point of sinking all that money into Homeland Security if this is the best we can do?
If you want to ignore rappers or raving partisans, fine. But don't use your column to divert people from the substantive problems that our government has in the area of disaster preparedness.
Anonymous (September 13, 2005 @ 10:20am):
" Not ONE person whose life has been devastated by this Hurricane cares at all about the finger-pointing and bickering from both extreme political sides, left or right. "
That is simply not true and, as usual, your talk radio mentality brings nothing to the table in this discussion.
We drove down to Mississippi to pick up some family members who had lost everything. Pointing fingers is the main topic of conversation among everyone we met from the Gulfport area. They had to have something to talk about when they were trapped in their attic.
Casey, do some research before you start acting so pius. I guess that it's easy for a middle-class white-boy coming from a comfy existence to proclaim that nobody has any business looking for blame at this point in time. Just like Barbara Bush and her take on this tragedy, you really need a clue too.
Anonymous (September 13, 2005 @ 7:27pm):
If the victims don't want to point fingers than how come 3 out of 4 blacks in america blame bush and his administration for this?
Anonymous (September 14, 2005 @ 12:01am):
It is important to remember that people would blame the president no matter what political party he was affiliated with. The point is, is that right now we need to focus on helping people. There will be plenty of blame to go around when all the panels form to take a look back and see "just where we went wrong", accomplishing nothing really except to stand across the room and shout out indignations.
Anonymous (September 14, 2005 @ 8:11am):
"It is important to remember that people would blame the president no matter what political party he was affiliated with. The point is, is that right now we need to focus on helping people. There will be plenty of blame to go around when all the panels form to take a look back and see "just where we went wrong", accomplishing nothing really except to stand across the room and shout out indignations."
-Brought to you by Karl Rove, Sean Hannity, Rush Limbaugh, Bill O'Reilly, Ann Coulter, Haliburton
