Opinion
Letter to Editor
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
Also by Jessi Schober:
- Bush begins new term on high note (February 1, 2005)
Have you hugged your abortion doctor today? Yes, today is National Day of Appreciation for Abortion Providers. A day of “remembering those who put their lives on the line daily to make choice possible” — the same “doctors” who eliminate real choice from the options that women have.
It is an outrage to celebrate such a heinous act. As the Feminists for Life state, abortion is not a symbol of women’s rights or choice, but instead is a “reflection that our society has failed to meet the needs of women.” We must not support abortion but instead support “systematically eliminating the root causes that drive women to abortion.”
Abortions need to be minimized. Since Roe v. Wade, abortion has killed 46 million children. Only 2.8 percent of women cite maternal health risks as their reason for an abortion. On the other hand, 25.5 percent of women simply wanted to postpone child bearing. These women, instead, need to embrace personal responsibility. There are over 3000 pregnancy crisis centers to counsel women.
Abortion is too common. Over 1.2 million abortions occur every year — that boils down to one abortion every 24 seconds.
When feminists argue that women’s rights are synonymous with abortion, they fail to mention the way in which abortion is destructive to women. Approximately 10 percent of women suffer immediate consequences, of which one-fifth are considered life-threatening. According to the Heritage House, after one legal abortion, the chance of premature birth increases threefold.
Abstinence is the fundamental way to decrease the necessity for abortions. After abstinence, programs must be in place to provide women with true options. “Choice” does not refer simply to whether or not you murder a fetus. Real “choice” refers to options of adoption and pregnancy crisis centers to provide counseling, shelter, and clothing. These “heroes” that selflessly “put their lives on the line” are doing nothing more than perpetuating a situation that will benefit their $400 million business.
I am a woman and I am pro-life. There are better options out there for us. I am not putting out a call to make abortion illegal; instead, I call to women to unite for the rights of our gender and the betterment of our society to make the need for abortion obsolete.
We must decrease the need for abortion and have a day of appreciation for abstinence, adoption, birth control and condoms — the alternatives to abortion. We must show our appreciation for the people who make adoption possible, who provide counseling to women and who educate men and women on safe and responsible sex — not the people who claim to “risk their lives” to take 3,600 lives a day.
Jessi Schober
jaschober@wisc.edu
15 Comments | Leave a comment
Leave a comment
Herald Blogs
The Beat Goes On
Muckrakers
President’s Visit Marked a Speech to One of the Last Groups Not Critical of Him
Extra Points
Top Classified Ads (view all)
HOUSES FOR Fall 2010. All houses are on W Dayton or N Bassett. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, or 8 bedrooms. All have parking. madisoncampusrentals.com





thanks jessi, this article is great. and thanks for adopting a bunch of unwanted kids, because we know you wouldn't be a hypocrite who doesn't want them either. and thanks for supporting birth control, unlike most pro-lifers who think that birth control equals promiscuity, and prevent women from acquiring it on 'religious' grounds.
how would not adopting unwanted kids make her a hypocrite? They are not her kids moron.
While I agree that a National Day of Appreciation for Abortion Providers is going overboard, here is what I always hate about pro-lifers. They try to extend their morality on everyone else. Now it's one thing to extend morality to certain things that the whole of society thinks are wrong: Murder, robbery, rape, fraud, etc. But a whole lot of us don't believe that abortion is murder. While I do believe that having less abortions by encouraging people to be more responsible with birth control would be preferrable, at some levels of society it just has not taken.
My fellow pro-choicers have a PR problem as well, as they often seem to come off as pro-abortion. That's an image I like to distance myself from as well. As a male who is pro-choice, if I got a girl pregnant the choice would be hers. If she wanted to have the baby, I would support her and be a father to the child. If she wanted an abortion, I would support her as well. Not enough men, though, would take the responsibility of raising the child.
Also, while having the child and giving it up for adoption sounds great, our foster care system isn't exactly wonderful, especially if a child is not adopted within the first year or so of life. While some would say, "Well, it's better to give them a chance," I would respond with, "For many of them it might be better if they were not born." Especially if everyone went to term, our foster care system would soon become like our prison system. Overcrowded and a drain on resources that can be better spent elsewhere.
But shouldn't you think about the effects that having sex can have on your life? Why not be responsible and think about your actions instead of worrying about it later...I guess one who believes in abortion would just say that having the abortion is being responsible...but why should we have so many chances in a situation like this...compared to other things...How many chances do we need to set ourselves right? Most likely if you get pregnant, you didn't wear a condom, you weren't on birth control, and you had sex...3 chances you had, 3 you chose to ignore, why do you deserve a 4th?
Because you're assuming all those things. Do you actually know that most women who have abortions didn't use birth control? Of course not, but that doesn't stop you from saying it.
If I'm sexually active, it's within a committed relationship, with some sort of birth control. I'm aware of my cycles and know when I'm ovulating - most fertile. Choosing to have an abortion would be a devastating decision, and would have nothing to do with 'chances'.
But how many women who have an abortion can say that they used both birth control and a condom? I'd be willing to guess less than a percent...if you didn't use both, and you chose to do the deed, who's fault is that then? Be responsible for your actions instead of taking the easy way out.
"Abortions need to be minimized. Since Roe v. Wade, abortion has killed 46 million children."
Please desribe to me how a fetus is a child before birth.
Also, you desribe in your article that "choice" is more than just abortion, it includes adoption and child care. While this is true, it is hypocrytical to then impose your personal beliefs on other women. As a woman, I am personally pro-life. I do not know if I could ever have an abortion, no matter what the circumstances. But I am politically pro-choice because I do not have the right nor the power to make that decision for other women. Many women give birth to children that they cannot financially or emotionally support. And no, they are not "killing a child" because a fetus is not the same thing as a living, breathing child.
Question to the writer: if you are so against abortions, are you also against birth control pills that stop a fertilized egg from planting itself and growing into a fetus? Do you just never have sex or what? That sounds like a sad life to me, and women have the complete right to take control of their bodies.
I have a true example as of this year that can explain my point: I know a girl, a freshman at Madison here, who became pregnant. She refused to have an abortion, even though she has $240 in the bank (not enough to support a child) because she was morally against it. Being a premiscuous girl, she went out and drank every weekend at the bar. A week later, she miscarried because of the heavy drinking, and this was confirmed the reason at UW Hospital. So do you mean to tell me that this child should have been born, having been an alcohol-syndrome baby to an irresponsible mother, or should this young woman have gotten an abortion and gotten her life on track?
The abortion issue really has two fundamenal parts, both of which have been brought up here: whether the fetus deserves the status of personhood, and whether the government has the right to legislate a view on the first subject.
Above, someone wrote, "describe to me how a fetus is a child before birth." I would like her to describe to me how a fetus five minutes before birth is substantially different from one five minutes afterward. Why does location, in or out of the womb, determine personhood? From the moment of conception the developing fetus is a human life independent of the mother. It may not have the same intelligence, consciousness, size, ability to feel pain, etc, that a full grown adult has, but since when have these been criteria by which we judge another human's worth under the law? Is a murderer less culpable if their victim is mentally disabled, asleep, a child, or sedated? Every human being is a person, whether it's convenient or not.
Given this belief, how can I remain passive in the face of legalized abortion? If the fetus is a human life, then abortion is a violation of its civil rights, and comes under the authority of civil government. This is not simply about private morality. The fact that a large part of the population does not agree with me does not mean that my view should be excluded from politics. After all, not everyone believes in universal health care (which could be described as a "moral" issue), but the Democrats would pass it if they could. Moreover, the moral status of the fetus does not vary from mother to mother; either all fetuses are persons or none of them. Therefore it's an issue that can be publicly determined one way or the other, and put into law.
P.S. "Do you just never have sex or what? That sounds like a sad life to me"--and here I thought that was happiness i've been feeling these 20 years.
I didn't just hug my abortion doctor today, I made a $100 donation to Planned Parenthood in honor of Jessi Schober.
That young girl wouldn't have had to decide whether or not to have an abortion if she had been a responsible person and understood the consequences to her actions. As for drinking every weekend and the baby dying...put her on trial...seriously...irresponsibility at its worst.
i don't think a fetus can survive outside of the woman's body when it is a few weeks old. there is a big difference between 5 min before it is born and conception
Why has no one mentioned the fact that this discussion is putting all of the blame on the women. You are forgetting that sex when not rape is a consensual act and should be protected by both parties. Also to whomever said that a fetus is an independent life without the mother do you know anything about the birth proccess because obviously if you did you would realize that a fetus is completly incapable of sustaining any kind of life without the mother. It's also pretty funny that you all mention a women seeking support and counseling from these support groups when "pro lifers" also generally advocate for the defunding of organizations like planned parenthood which offer these services.
Im going to hug my abortion doctor today and say thanks for respecting mine and every womens right to chose what is done to her body
Why has no one mentioned the fact that this discussion is putting all of the blame on the women. You are forgetting that sex when not rape is a consensual act and should be protected by both parties. Also to whomever said that a fetus is an independent life without the mother do you know anything about the birth proccess because obviously if you did you would realize that a fetus is completly incapable of sustaining any kind of life without the mother. It's also pretty funny that you all mention a women seeking support and counseling from these support groups when "pro lifers" also generally advocate for the defunding of organizations like planned parenthood which offer these services.
Im going to hug my abortion doctor today and say thanks for respecting mine and every womens right to chose what is done to her body
Why has no one mentioned the fact that this discussion is putting all of the blame on the women. You are forgetting that sex when not rape is a consensual act and should be protected by both parties. Also to whomever said that a fetus is an independent life without the mother do you know anything about the birth proccess because obviously if you did you would realize that a fetus is completly incapable of sustaining any kind of life without the mother. It's also pretty funny that you all mention a women seeking support and counseling from these support groups when "pro lifers" also generally advocate for the defunding of organizations like planned parenthood which offer these services.
Im going to hug my abortion doctor today and say thanks for respecting mine and every womens right to chose what is done to her body
In response to the original article, you quote Feminists For Life as stating abortion as a ?reflection that our society has failed to meet the needs of women.? I don't always agree with feminist theory, and I don't have the context this statement was made in, but I find it right on target as the primary root of this practice. They are more right then they know. Our society, in part because of feminist theory, as well as many other reasons, has lost it's ability to define and enforce a man's role as defender and equal partner in his own family. The vast majority of abortions happen as the result of a view of no other choice left for a single mother who has been used by a man and discarded, he has truly failed her. No one taught this man he needs to defend his family at all cost, rather than leave his son or daughter for dead. It is those who love every human life and cherish every child who find this practice unacceptable behavior not just of the Mother, but of the Father. Those who feel that a child is alive only when one is expected, fail to notice the difference between a Father, and a hormonally driven boy. A real man, who knows how to love fully and selflessly, would love his wife so much that he would love every part of her, womb and all. It would break his heart to see any part of her die. So, to see a person who is glad, or relieved an abortion took place, is to gain an insight into a culture of death and hate. True love chooses life. Thus, perhaps hugs for abortion docs are just what the doctor ordered, not in approval, but in erosion to their hate. -Stu S.