News
UW dismisses Kindles for classroom education
Inaccessibility cited as reason to reject; need improvements
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
Also by Anna Asendorf:
- UW to begin clinical trial on new vaccine which helps quit smoking (January 29, 2010)
- Officials see decrease in binge drinking among UW students (January 27, 2010)
- Lack of funding ends social networking course (December 10, 2009)
- First mass clinic at SERF to vaccinate students for H1N1 (December 4, 2009)
- UW-Madison slips in Trojan collegiate sexual health rankings (November 29, 2009)
Sharing tools:
E-mail this article:
After experimenting with Amazon’s electronic reading device — the Kindle DX — in the classroom, the University of Wisconsin has decided it will not adopt the current version of the device for general use due to its inaccessibility to the blind.
While the Kindle DX provides text-to-speech technology in the reading of texts, the operation of the menu lacks this feature, making the device difficult to use by the blind.
Ken Frazier, UW director of libraries, who also initiated the UW pilot Kindle program, openly criticized the device for this reason in a statement put out by the National Federation for the Blind.
“My intent in participating in the NFB release was to urge Amazon to make the device accessible,” Frazier said.
Frazier and Aaron Brower, vice chancellor of education, integrated the use of 20 Kindle DX’s in Professor Jeremi Suri’s upper-level history seminar to understand and evaluate the potential of new technological devices to replace textbooks in the future.
“Textbooks as we have them are dinosaurs,” Brower said. “The question is what are they going to become and how are we going to shape them?”
Suri described the impacts of the Kindle DX as “overwhelmingly positive.” Flexibility, reduced textbook prices and convenience were among positive responses from students, he said.
However, the negative barrier the device poses to the blind was an issue Frazier said he felt needed to be addressed.
Frazier said he believes universities can play a large role in influencing the marketplace to do the right thing. Devices like the Kindle DX have the potential to create an enormous library of books currently unavailable to the blind, but the technology has to work for them, Frazier said.
Gregg Vanderheiden, professor of industrial and biomedical engineering and director of the UW Trace Research and Development Center, said he supports Frazier’s stance and described Amazon’s failure to create accessible menus and controls for the blind as shortsighted.
“I think it is exactly the correct decision. UW has a long reputation for embracing diversity and accommodating people with disabilities. There is no technical reason for the Kindle not to be accessible,” he said. “The university is a leader and innovator in the education field. For it to say we are not going to proceed with the Kindle if the Kindle is not designed for all students — that is significant.”
Vanderheiden and Frazier both predict the availability of fully accessible devices for the blind in the near future.
While the experiment with the Kindle DX in a UW course had both advantages and disadvantages, the future of technology in education is important, Brower said.
“Everyone gets to participate in the creation and sharing of knowledge. It is a really different and engaging way to think about knowledge and education and teaching others. I am looking forward to the way technology is pushing forward,” he said.
2 Comments | Leave a comment
Leave a comment
Top Classified Ads (view all)
Place your classified ad online and have it show up here. Your ad will hit thousands of viewers a day!
DON'T READ ME! Too late. If you're reading this, guess how many other people are reading it. See... advertising in The Badger Herald does work!
IP hash: 97454428
The normal books we have now aren’t accessible to the blind either!
We can’t go forward with new technology that will save students hundreds of dollars every semester because the Kindle doesn’t have text-to-speech for navigating the menu??? That’s the only hangup?
Really, how many blind students would this even realistically affect? First, you gotta be blind. Second, you want to use the Kindle (I’m not blind and I don’t want to use the Kindle). Third, your curriculum has to be available for the Kindle (this will take years to happen anyway). Fourth, if the first three are all true, you have to be willing to make a big political stink about it like you’re the most important person in the world that everyone must accommodate.
Meanwhile, the rest of us are discriminated against. And current paper books don’t accommodate the blind either. Lose-lose.
IP hash: a85697fa
This is not about the blind. It especially doesn’t make any sense considering how many supplementary texts, powerpoint slides etc aren’t even accessible to the blind now, or will be in the foreseeable future.
This is about the publishers pressuring Mr. Frazier to prevent the switchover. The kindle siphons profits from the publisher’s massive margin, and that of course is unacceptable. I’d be willing to bet the university book store is also against this, as there would be no more used books for them to sell!! Once again, the UW’s bureaucracy gets into the way of progress.