News: Top story

Abortion issue sparks protest

Groups rally against each other over MSC’s plan for 2nd-trimester procedures

Abortion issue sparks protest

Enlarge image

LOGAN CASCIA/Herald photo

UW student Alicia Casanova participates in an abortion rights rally at Library Mall in support of MSC.

Also by Joanna Klass:
Sharing tools:

E-mail this article:




 

Vote 0 Votes

Anti-abortion and abortion rights supporters rallied in front of the Madison Surgery Center Saturday in preparation for the UW Hospital Authority Board vote this Wednesday regarding the clinic’s decision to offer second-trimester abortions.

The clash came after the clinic’s announcement in December to begin performing second-trimester abortions after the only local provider stopped offering them due to the retirement of Planned Parenthood physician Dennis Christensen, according to NARAL Pro-Choice Wisconsin and Foundation Executive Director Lisa Subeck.

The two sides met after anti-abortion activists gathered at Library Mall to listen to speakers. The group then proceeded to march down Lake Street to the MSC, where they met abortion rights supporters.

The two groups chanted back and forth across Regent Street for about 45 minutes before dispersing. The rally was mostly peaceful, although UW police were forced to block off part of Regent Street to prevent protesters from interrupting traffic.

“There hasn’t been a movement in the streets for women’s rights in decades. The (women’s rights) movement has been defensive. The movement’s been apologizing for its demands,” said Chris Dols, a UW senior and International Socialist Organization member.

Subeck said taking away the option of second-trimester abortion restricts women’s rights to be entitled to a full range of reproductive health care.

“Sometimes there is a medical complication discovered that they didn’t know about during their first trimester and sometimes people don’t have access [to abortion] during the first trimester,” Subeck said.

Anti-abortion advocate Haywood Robinson, a family physician from College Station, Texas, disagreed with the definition of health care outlined by abortion rights supporters.

Robinson argued abortion is not part of health care because pregnancy is not a disease. He went on to say abortions also put mothers at medical risk.

UW freshman Ethan Schuler said there are more appropriate choices.

“It’s a difficult situation for both parties. Everyone has difficulties and challenges and everyone has their cross to carry. Killing is not a way to get rid of that cross,” Schuler said.

Advocates on both sides expressed confidence the board will vote in their favor.

Subeck said she is confident they will earn a “yes” from the board, though the strength of the anti-abortion movement has been a force in Wisconsin for the past three decades.

“We don’t know what God’s plan is, but we have had indication that Meriter has had some hesitation,” UW alumna Laura Karlen said.

Dols is determined to keep the abortion rights presence strong.

“These are growing pains — the movement for abortion without apologies is back,” Dols said. “Anytime the right wing rears its ugly head, we’ll be here to counter their lies.”

The board will vote on the matter Wednesday. They will be the third body voicing an opinion on MSC’s decision, the previous two being in support of offering second-trimester abortions.


16 Comments | Leave a comment

Ms. Klass,

I am sorry to see that you decided not to even attempt to do objective journalism here. The pro-life movement draws 2,000 people, and the 60 raving socialists get the top billing in your article?

Steve

When the reporter interviewed me, she told me she didn’t attend the event. She just arrived for the aftermath. It’s hard to expect accurate reporting if she didn’t bother to show up.

Laura Karlen

Oh puke.

Imagine a TV/video commercial:
It shows an ultrasound of an unborn baby while a caption reads, ‘The child’s future is a broken home. He will be abandoned by his father. His single mother will struggle to raise him. Despite hardships, the child will become the first African-American president.’

Life — Imagine the Potential.

Hope! Change! Abort!

What I’m disgusted with, besides the abysmal “objective” coverage, is the fact that the Badger Herald feels the need to gloss over this issue naming the sides “abortion rights” and “anti-abortion”. They’re pro-choice and pro-life. If you’re going to be objective, Badger Herald, you might want to frame things more positively instead of AGAIN putting the more conservative viewpoint as the rejected, anti-viewpoint.

What would Bill Buckley say?

Uh 12:42, “pro-abortion rights” and “anti-abortion” are much more objective than “pro-choice” or “pro-life.”

Argue the sides, not the political correctness of the terms used to describe them.

user-pic

It seems so very ironic that such a liberal, pro-abortion president, Obama, was a very good candidate himself to be aborted by his own mother. One would think that would cause him to think about this issue a little more clearly. Obviously many of the people on the pro-abortion side haven’t counseled a woman that has made this decision that will haunt her for the rest of her life.

i like to say that you are either pro-life or pro-death. saying ‘choice’ makes people fell not as bad about themselves when they should simply say they are pro-death.

According to the 2008 AP Style book, the correct terminology to use in journalistic work for pro-life is anti-abortion. For pro-abortion the correct wording is abortion rights. Take that 12:42 p.m.! If you are going to talk shit about the terrible “objective” work, make sure YOU know what you are talking about before you go on your own little rant.

Pro-life, pro-death, anti-abortion, pro-baby eating - the nomenclature is not the issue, but the discussion thus far has been amusing. I wonder how much longer both sides will continue to argue over semantics before delving into the meaty goodness of the issue. (But while I’m on the topic, I like the idea of being pro-death. It also makes me feel less guilty about laughing at the Darwin Awards.)

To the poster dreaming up the TV commercial, here’s an alternate take for you:

The first shot is a close-up of a smiling mother and child at the park. The mother is pushing the child on the swing, and both are laughing.

The next shot is of the child crying in the arms of her father at her mother’s funeral. Neither the child’s mother nor the child with whom she was pregnant survived the life threatening complications that occurred during her pregnancy.

This child will grow up without her mother. Pre-natal testing identified the risks, but an abortion wasn’t available in the community where the family lives.

Or perhaps another one: The first shot shows a teenaged girl in a courtroom watching as her attacker is sentenced to 20 years in prison for raping her.

In the second shot, the teenager and her mother are in the bathroom staring at a stick with a telltale plus sign on it.

Should she be forced to carry this product of rape inside her for 9 months? I mean, Imagine the potential.

Wow. This paper just keeps getting worse. Even the police said that the pro-life delegation had the socialists outnumbered by easily more than 20 to 1. But who does the article highlight? The handful of greasy-haired hippies who showed up to scream obscenities. This isn’t journalism, this is just spin. What absolute tripe. Miss Klass, from one journalist to another, you are a disgrace.

It doesn’t matter how many holy rollers show up for a rally. Nothing is going to change. Get used to it.

Holy Smokes Moochie it looks like you made a ton of enemies writing this article.

For all the men that bothered to comment on this article and state their anti-abortion attitudes, you will NEVER understand how a women feels when she discovers she is pregnant, especially if she is a teenager without the support of her family or the father of her child. It is impossible for me to fathom how people can condemn an action when they themselves have never been in that situation.

Because one has never raped a gal, one should not condemn rape?

Leave a comment

To comment anonymously or if signed in, leave name and e-mail blank.

Place a shout-out!
Top Classified Ads (view all)

HOUSES FOR Fall 2010. All houses are on W Dayton or N Bassett. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, or 8 bedrooms. All have parking. madisoncampusrentals.com

Place a classified ad

Advertising