News
Catholic group sues UW again
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
Also by Carl Jaeger:
- Bus fare increase proposal shot down (December 10, 2008)
- Voice of the students (December 4, 2008)
- Budget shortfall projected to hit $5 billion (November 12, 2008)
Following years of legal disagreements, the Roman Catholic Foundation of the University of Wisconsin has once again filed a lawsuit against UW.
Formerly known as the University of Wisconsin Roman Catholic Foundation, RCF-UW filed the lawsuit against UW late Monday afternoon.
Alliance Defense Fund attorney David French, who is representing RCF-UW, said the lawsuit was filed because UW was not abiding by its settlement with the organization, which occurred last May.
In the settlement, UW approved $253,274 in student-segregated fees for RCF-UW and, in return, the organization agreed to separate itself from St. Paul's Catholic Church.
"The RCF and the university agreed to a settlement where the university would agree to fund the RCF's budget request for the 07-08 school year, and that they would then put [the RCF's] budget request through no greater scrutiny than any other group," French said in an interview with The Badger Herald.
Immediately after the settlement in May, however, French said UW began placing stipulations on certain budget items — including religious events and materials — and then denied several elements of the budget request that had been approved in the agreement.
"They indicated that they were denying them on grounds that are unlawful — not only in violation of the settlement agreement, but in violation of the Constitution," French said.
French added that RCF-UW didn't want to be treated as second-class citizens, and only want to be "treated the same as everyone else when they apply for funds from the system."
John Lucas, a spokesperson for UW, issued a statement Monday calling the lawsuit "baseless," and said UW has always treated RCF in the same manner as any other religious student organization.
"The university has always tried to strike a balance between supporting student activities and meeting our obligation under the law," the statement said. "Like the federal government, we are unable to fund inherently religious activities, such as worship, religious instruction or proselytization."
French said through the lawsuit the organization hopes to establish the rights and obligations of both the RCF-UW and the university.
"The goal here is to get some absolute clarity as to what the university's obligations are [and] what RCF's rights are," French said. "We could be looking at quite a lengthy litigation process because I'm not so certain that RCF would enter into any kind of agreement unless the assurance in the agreement were iron-clad and immediately enforceable."
As recently as last November, RCF-UW filed a lawsuit against UW citing violations of the organization’s First Amendment rights by not funding the group due to its religious affiliation.
An additional lawsuit was filed six days later after the Associated Students of Madison's Student Services Finance Committee denied the group contract status — a status that would allow RCF-UW additional funding.
Although RCF-UW was again denied contract status last Thursday, French said the decision to file the lawsuit was unrelated, saying "the timing of the lawsuit [was] actually dictated by the university's denials."
French said he was hopeful the lawsuit would provide clarity for both RCF-UW and UW.
RCF-UW Chair Beth Czarnecki said the organization held a board meeting Monday night to discuss the lawsuit, but declined to comment further on the issue.
12 Comments | Leave a comment
Leave a comment
Herald Blogs
The Beat Goes On
Brother Ali makes an ‘Exclusive’ stop
Muckrakers
Report: Barrett to make decision by the end of the week
Extra Points
Top Classified Ads (view all)
HOUSES FOR Fall 2010. All houses are on W Dayton or N Bassett. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, or 8 bedrooms. All have parking. madisoncampusrentals.com





Church group, please stop bothering the public school.
“RCF-UW didn’t want to be treated as second-class citizens”
Oh, like they treat gays?
I’m pretty sure the constitution says church and state have to be separate…….so why is a church group fighting for a public/state funded university’s money??? Quit wasting UWs time and find another means to fund your dumb organization.
If RCF spent as much time looking for funding or focusing on the organizations activities as they do fighting UW they would be a rather weathly and successful group…
For all the Christian haters: The First Amendment protects all speech, including that of a religious nature. Oh, and it also protects speech regardless of whether you happen to like or agree with the speech. Re-read it if you’re not clear on that point.
Yes, like they treat gays as evidenced by being the largest non-government provider on aids related funding. Religion is another measure of diversity whose inclusion should be celebrated by UW.
Seg fees for student organizations are taxations on student body implemented by liberal representatives in ASM some years ago. Seg fees should be abolished, but as long as they are still around, both liberal and religious(conservative) organizations alike should receive funding as long as they meet the criteria. Just because you don’t agree with the group or will never take part in its activities, doesn’t mean that the group doesn’t deserve a piece of the seg fees. I am not a member of RCF, but their funds are going to better uses unlike those given to Sex Out Loud for dildos, sex technique classes, and cases upon cases of condoms. RCF has seen the most criticism out of any seg fee funded group, even after several court rulings in their favor. My advice is if you don’t like where funding is going, voice your opinion at SSFC meetings and elect people to ASM that will change the way seg fees are handled.
Hey you Constitutional scholars, show me where there is any mention of separation of Church and State. Guess what, ya can’t!! I can go one further, provided funding is not because of the religious nature of the group, there is no endorsement (as some would like to claim).
You’ve all seen the first part of Zeitgeist, right? So Christianity is really merely a spin on the astrological view of the world of yesteryear. So let go of your fixation, OK?
$254,000 per year. Let me repeat that for effect. $254,000 per year.
Is that Religous Freedom or Greed?
I (and hundreds of others), have to pay an activity fee to play in the All University String Orchestra (which is actually a college credit coarse). I do so because its an activity I enjoy and I dont complain.
Likewise UW-RCF should make its members fund its budget, or find outside funding. Instead, the UW-RCF is exploiting a seriously flawed system to extort large sums of money from UW Students and then they pretend like they are the victums.
The only reason I pay seg fees is so I can get my diploma. I doubt I am alone in this position. It takes alot of chutzpah for UW-RCF to complain about getting only $254,000 of free money from college students like me.
to the previous poster: where do you get the idea that UW-RCF is complaining about getting $254,000? They’re trying to spend the money that has been allotted to them.
As for the size of the budget, they’re representing or offering resources for what is a large population on this campus - like it or not, many people hold religious beliefs and many people are Catholic.
Student orgs of all sizes and types are given money, so when considering the size of the operations that go on in serving such a large population, the amount of money isn’t so outrageous.
On a side note, this university once gave land to religious groups because President Charles Van Hise and many others saw the quite appropriate placement of them in realm higher education and life in general. That’s why you have the Pres House, St. Paul’s, and the Lutheran Chapel all in a row at the foot of State Street.
Religion isn’t the enemy; religious diversity has been a part of our university’s history since the beginning. And there are many students who benefit immensely from groups like these.
I understand your argument. However, with or without seg fee’s, Catholic students would have no problem organizing. Likewise, there are many other groups that shouldn’t be recieving seg fee’s, or at least not as much. The system in place is too easy to extort. The UW-RCF is just the most obvious example of the problem. It has nothing to due with its religous connections. I would like a system where I could opt-out of paying seg fees but be denied access to seg fee programs/groups.
The catholic group does not need the 254,000 dollars. They have a perfectly functioning church. They soon will have a cathedral in downtown madison. They have another church immediatly behind the Highlander housing complex.
What they want is money, which they cannot justify getting given the amount of backing they could get and do get from outside sources such as the bishop. They are a poorly cloaked side-project of Bishop Morilno and not an authentic independent student organization.
Does the Lutheran Student group get money? No. They meet at Calvary Lutheran Church. The Muslims meet on campus but have office space in someone’s apartment. The catholic’s (and I am one) need to quit complaining. For the love of God quit acting like babies. Stop looking out for yourself and start doing for others.
What happened to the meals for the poor that used to run at St. Pauls? Those are gone. What happend to the greed of the church … It’s grown large with a very unchristian pride sense of pride and entitlement. for a bunch of conservatives, you sound like welfare whores.