ArtsEtc.
Carey’s latest release doesn’t add up
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
Also by Christine Bohn:
- Touch of campfire in Colin Meloy (April 15, 2008)
- 'Drillbit Taylor' cons nerds, viewers (March 24, 2008)
- Lyrical message onstage, in heart (March 13, 2008)
- Pub punks' latest ideal for March (March 7, 2008)
- New patisserie sweetens the scene on Cap Square (February 14, 2008)
Sharing tools:
E-mail this article:
You would never know Mariah Carey had been nominated for six Grammy Awards after listening to her new album E=MC^2. In fact, there isn’t much to say about this monotonous disaster other than this: The album is nowhere near as brilliant as Einstein’s legendary formula.
Seven years after her meltdown, Mariah Carey fans were given false hopes for this CD after U.S. radios released her single “Touch My Body” in February. Sadly, the album is similar to that of a playlist at a middle school dance; the beats are all the same, and — what’s worse — they’re all mid-tempo, making everyone confused as to whether they should be slow dancing or grinding the night away.
She opens E=MC^2 with “Migrate.” On this song — which features the infamous T-Pain — Mariah sings of how all the men love her and how she will have to migrate with them “From the party to the after party,” providing just the first of many overdone R&B innuendos.
Carey boosts her ego even further with “Touch My Body,” “Cruise Control” and “I’m That Chick,” singing about boys lovin’ girls — well, specifically boys loving her — and vice-versa. However, the only song that manages to have a semi-respectable beat in this trio is “I’m That Chick,” which gives listeners the impression that they have regressed to the days of disco.
Songs “I Stay in Love,” “Love Story” and “For the Record” are slow and typical of a mid-’90s artist — poor lyrics, repetitive beats and too much hype. And if it wasn’t easy enough to tell from their titles, these tunes are, once again, about love and Carey’s apparent commitment to men.
Similarly, “I’ll Be Lovin’ U Long Time” sports the same theme but does so in a Mariah Carey-turns-Jamaican fashion, and she makes sure to carry this Jamaican theme into her lyrics as well. This is the most upbeat song out of the entire album — but that doesn’t say much.
Carey decides that there is too much talk about love and herself in this album thus far, so she offers “Last Kiss,” “Thanx 4 Nothin’” — yes, I am spelling these correctly — and “O.O.C.” to bring down the mood a bit and sing instead about break-ups. For the cultured folk out there, “O.O.C.” includes a touch of the Spanish and French languages. Carey sings, “Te quiero mucho Papi/ Je ne sais pas mais c’est la vie.” For those of you unable to decipher this doozy of a phrase, it means “I love Papi a lot/ I don’t know but that’s life.” Deep, ain’t it?
To conclude a dull album, Carey thought a piano ballad would be a great way for her audience to remember how “great” her CD is. Yet another slow song with lulling gospel overtones, Carey changes it up by including Bible verses from the Book of Proverbs, John, Philippians and Psalms in “I Wish You Well.”
The only positive thing that comes out of this mess of a record is that people who grew up in the ’90s can sit back and remember the good ol’ days — and then proceed to realize why everyone and their neighbors told us to turn off that god-awful music.
1 out 5 stars
12 Comments | Leave a comment
Leave a comment
Herald Blogs
The Beat Goes On
Fans of Waits will not be disappointed
Muckrakers
Report: Barrett to make decision by the end of the week
Extra Points
Top Classified Ads (view all)
SPRING SUBLET: 1 bedroom in 2 bedroom at the Aberdeen. Rent negotiable. Email arkramer@wisc.edu
GENTLE WOMEN...THROUGH the lens of Douglas J. Nesbit, newly released book now available for holiday gifts! www.gentlewomen.us
IP hash: 318cfb54
This is way to harsh of a review. I believe that this is some of Mariah’s best work. Eveysong is a hit.
IP hash: fdfa6721
Don’t you hate it when your review is far off what the rest of the industry gave this album… and average of 3 or 4 out of 5. Yes not as great as her previous but great in its own right.
IP hash: 47356409
Haha.
This review is a joke . The album is on fire! Probably an undercover Madonna lover.
Meh.
IP hash: d742dac9
WOW. Who is this Christine Bohn? Are you deaf; or do you just hate Mariah Carey? From what I hear, the album has already sold over 200k copies in its first 2 days. Someone must really like it. But what do you know? You work for the Badger! Get a life. Mariah could sing about paint drying and it would be beautiful.
IP hash: d742dac9
You must be deaf. This is one of her best albums. Someone must like it. According to SoundScan, it has sold over 200k copies in its first 2 days since being released. Stop hating! Sounds to me, you have something agains MIMI. She has a beautiful voice and unlike most of the POPTARTS, she writes her own lyrics. Get a life!
IP hash: e66057d8
apparently there are a lot of defensive mariah lovers on campus.
IP hash: f58d671b
Mariah Carey sucks, and she always has. She is a f*cking psycho for that matter. good review
IP hash: 8c5f5ef9
Another Mariah hater. How can anything she writes be trusted when she cant even get the facts straight. Mariah has 33 - yes, 33- grammy nominations. Not 6. Who is the writer and why is she being allowed to publish such nonsense?
IP hash: 27671adf
I got the album the day it was released and have been listening to it ever since. I’m sure the album is on repeat on your ipod. No wait, you’re probably too cool for an ipod.
IP hash: 27671adf
yes, get your facts straight. I heart Mariah!!
IP hash: 2c48e377
Hey, I like Mariah too but you do have to admit this CD is monotonous. It is a throwback to 90’s music. I had greater expectations of her.
IP hash: 845b0589
you are all idiots. Just because an album sells well that doesn’t mean its good music. Mariah used to be good but she has sold out just like most other pop icons. Stop watching MTV and listen to some good music for a change. Excellent review