High school is just one long
popularity contest. �Charlie Bartlett� proves this with hilarity and
affection through the title character�s journey from a prep school expellee to
a public school phenomenon.�
The high school characters � besides Charlie (Anton Yelchin,
�Alpha Dog�), of course � are stereotyped into representatives of every
standard clique. Yet despite each individual�s designated posse, cheerleaders,
bullies, drama geeks and quiet, suicidal loners all eventually come to Charlie
for advice, or just someone to talk to. Charlie is a psychiatrist eager to
prescribe, who also has a penchant for a bad streak. With a little help from a
drug dealer bully, the school is flooded with prescription drugs ranging from
Xanax to Zoloft, all provided through Charlie.
The film embellishes the high school atmosphere a little
from time to time, but what movie of this caliber doesn�t? In one scene, a gymnasium
full of teenagers take Ritalin during their school dance, but not a single
person is reprimanded in the slightest.
Charlie�s charisma prevails throughout the film, as
demonstrated by a bevy of misguided youths who still seek his empathetic peer
counseling after one customer tries to off himself with an overdose, causing Charlie
to temporarily shut down the mini-pharmacy he administers from the boys�
bathroom.
Students address Charlie with all sorts of personal
problems, ranging from a breast implant dilemma to the loose cheerleader unable
to find a stable relationship because she puts out on the first date.
One of the most memorable roles in �Charlie Bartlett� is that
of a scruffy Robert Downey Jr. as the alcoholic Principal Gardner. Scenes of
whisky guzzling, self-loathing and neurosis appear pretty close to home,
creating moments that are both funny and depressing. Downey does especially
well in a climactic scene involving a near-empty bottle of booze, a swimming
pool, a remote-controlled motorboat and a handgun.
Downey�s character was only outdone in a few scenes, each
involving the absurdity of Charlie�s mother (Hope Davis, �The Hoax�), a classy
ex-hippy who � always with a courteous smile � is completely devoid of common
sense.
The characters are admittedly a bit over-the-top, but that
doesn�t stop them from being likeable. The notion of America�s youth being fed
prescription drugs and put under heavy surveillance for control is not easily overlooked
or easily missed.
In truth, there isn�t much substance to this film, and the
substance that exists is hardly revolutionary, and the whole feel-good attitude
of it doesn�t always jive well with the serious issues it tries to address.
In the end, it is Charlie Bartlett�s overwhelming
personality and Yelchin�s performance that really make this film. The blue
blazer prep school might ring a �Rushmore� bell, but the movie definitely has
more of a �Ferris Bueller�s Day Off� feel to it. Charlie�s charismatic antics
lead him on a quest for popularity, which is understandable, but his ultimate
realization and the resolution of the film don�t quite pay off.
Go see this movie, but don�t expect it to be an instant
classic.
�
3 stars out of 5


