ArtsEtc.
‘SNL,’ ‘Mad TV’ debate riles columnist
Looking for a print version?
Simply use your browser’s ‘Print’ command and a printer-friendly document will be generated automatically.
Also by Mike Peters:
- Simpsons to hit silver screen (May 4, 2007)
- Hats off to three funnymen (April 27, 2007)
- Kings of Comedy list needs revision (April 20, 2007)
- TV execs clean out best shows (April 13, 2007)
- End of 'Punk'd' better be true (March 30, 2007)
Sharing tools:
E-mail this article:
Flipping through the channels one evening, I stumbled on the E! network, which is usually territory I attempt to avoid. The only two adequate excuses I can come up with for watching E! are: (1) hoping the censors forgot to blur out some boobs on "The Girls Next Door" or (2) watching a classic episode of "Saturday Night Live."
What caught my attention was not an "SNL" rerun, however, but an "SNL" countdown. E! aired a program titled "101 Most Unforgettable SNL Moments." The special itself was a rerun, being a couple years old. But that's not going to stop me from complaining about it.
The countdown was insanely flawed. In fact, it almost drove me to insanity. I'm already teetering on the brink as it is, and this show almost put me over the edge.
Eddie Murphy proclaiming "I'm Gumby, Dammit!" was No. 101. No. 101? Usually on such countdowns, the last spot is reserved for something that barely even deserves to be on the list. "I'm Gumby, Dammit!" definitely deserves a spot and a higher one at that. For instance, how is "The Denise Show" — ranked at 95 — more memorable than Gumby? The skit occurred like three times at most, and each instance was marginally funny at best. It's not that I don't remember it, but on the trip down memory lane, "I'm Gumby, Dammit!" belongs in a mansion while "The Denise Show" should have a shack.
I have so many complaints about this list, I could write about it every week until winter break and only get down to No. 90. However, complaining about the list is not why I began with this anecdote.
This list really got me thinking about how awful "Mad TV" is. "Mad TV" would never have a special with its 101 most unforgettable moments. Why? Because they're not sellouts? No. "Mad TV" would sell out in a heartbeat if it could. The reason they would never have a countdown is because "Mad TV" does not have memorable moments. Almost everything about "Mad TV" is forgettable. Most people couldn't even name 10 memorable moments from the show. I'm hoping some reader will try to, and I look forward to hearing what he or she has to say. Seriously, I'd really like to know if it has done anything worth remembering.
Why is this show so unimportant? Most of all, the show is not very funny. When I do watch it, which isn't often but enough to pass judgment, I feel like the writers and performers aren't even trying. The recurring characters are even more repetitive and tiresome than the characters on "SNL," which is an incredible act to pull off. If I see Stuart, Michael McDonald's childlike character, one more time, I will surely be pushed well over the aforementioned brink.
On top of that, the supposedly topical humor is often weeks (or more) out-of-date. Without the advantage of airing live, "Mad TV" has almost no reason to exist, especially in competition with "SNL." The best decision they could make is to lose the topical humor. The show will never be able beat "SNL" in that area.
That is what makes "Mad TV" so insignificant, and "SNL" a part of our culture. In fact, "SNL" is so much a part of our culture, NBC is banking on two new primetime programs based on the famed late-night sketch comedy show.
The first, which premiered on Monday, is "Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip." This is an hour-long drama created by Aaron Sorkin of "West Wing" and "Sports Night" fame. The show is a behind-the-scenes peek into the production of a fictional sketch comedy show. The second, which will premiere Oct. 11 (the same day "SNL" premiered in 1975), is "30 Rock." This is a half-hour-long comedy created by Tina Fey of "SNL" and "Mean Girls" fame. The show is a behind-the-scenes peek into the production of a fictional sketch comedy show.
The synopses are identical. Personally, if I'm going to watch a show about sketch comedy, I'll take the funny one. I realize "Studio 60" has funny moments, but the fact that it's classified as a drama turns me off immediately. It's like if NBC aired a new hour-long drama entitled "They Call Me Bob" in which Bob creates a list of everything he has done wrong in his life and sets out to right his wrongs, with semi-humorous results, but not so humorous as to be considered a rip-off of any existing NBC show.
Also, notice how the half-hour-long comedy has 30 in its title and the hour-long drama contains 60. Coincidence? Probably, but it sure makes the shows a lot easier to distinguish. That's good marketing, NBC.
Finally, let's not forget that "SNL" will soon be back with its 32nd season — a number I hope and predict "Mad TV" will never reach. "Saturday Night Live" may not exactly be as hip as it once was, and most college students prefer to spend their Saturday nights getting wasted, so I'm going to make a drinking game you can play while watching the show. When you hear "Live from New York, it's Saturday night," take 20 shots. That's the game. Now enjoy the show.
Mike Peters is a senior focusing on communication arts, film and business. Want to talk comedy with him? Send questions or comments his way at mpeters@badgerherald.com.
4 Comments | Leave a comment
Leave a comment
Herald Blogs
The Beat Goes On
Brother Ali makes an ‘Exclusive’ stop
Muckrakers
Report: Barrett to make decision by the end of the week
Extra Points
Top Classified Ads (view all)
HOUSES FOR Fall 2010. All houses are on W Dayton or N Bassett. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, or 8 bedrooms. All have parking. madisoncampusrentals.com
are you serious? you don’t know comedy
Agreed. Mad TV sucks ass.
10 memorable moments from Mad TV:
Paranoid Boss Like many that you will hear about, the first was the funniest. When a sketch is funny on Mad TV, you can tell. It does not need to be “memorable”. The humor is timeless.
American Idol winners & runner-ups singing This began an expisode, and it is ordinary, but at least it was carried out superbly. All of their sketches are done smoothly. Every body who imitates imitates well, if not in looks, in voice. All you have to do is compare voices of Dr. Phil, George W.Bush, Simon Cowell, Oprah (before the last Season), Renee Zellweger, HSN, Rod Rodney, or anyone else. Mad wins in this department.
Modern Honeymooners They have shown it alot in the past, that is probably due to how funny it was. There will be more, stay tuned for the upcoming Season, hopefully there will be more.
“Zombie Party” It appeared nearly at the end of Season 10. Watch it. You will be hurling with hysterical laughter. I did.
House Mad has done other Mad TV reenactments. This one is the funniest out of all of. Look for them, and especially this.
“Shaq & the Super Lakers” I think that is how it went. They did multiple animated television programs of it, so if you keep your eye on reruns, you will find it again.
White House Wife Swap Around election time, they took both first ladys and did a FOX version of wife swap. Surpassed anything that Saturday Night Live did for the reelections. The “Depressed Pedrsian Toe Truck Man…” with John Kerry is in the same range as hilarious 2004 election humor. The 2nd Debate was funny as well, and since Mad TV was on earlier they did not have to do all of the debates in one episode, they could of spread it around and when it happened in real time- unlike SNL.
Ashlee Simpson sketch This one is mean. They take Ashlee Simpson and have her sing a terribly worded “Pieces of Me”, secretly sync her voice to other singers, and have her berated by everyone around her. It has to be at least third for memorability.
Craig He did some segments where he would just act out. The one with his father was the funniest one, and he introduced “Zombie Party”.
1.Kenny Rogers does “Jackass” Nothing more needa to be said. You can take 70% of Saturday Night Live and not nearly even get within the same league as a decent Kenny Rogers impersonator getting trashed by the real Jackass crew. It is impossible to contain the laughter, everytime I watched or think back to this sketch.
Mike, Saturday Night live’s comedy has gone tremendously down-hill every since Tina Fey became head writer. The show screams for “cheap laughter” by having actors laugh in the middle of skits because the jokes are not creative or funny. Saturday Night Live’s skits continue on far too long, drawing out a skit on the idea of one joke just to kill time. Mad TV in the past few years has had a far better amount of skits like their “Sopranos” skits or “GUMP FICTION”. These are very memorable moments of comedy. But tonight I saw mad TV trying to immitate SNL style skits. They inserted SNL’s “theory of actor laughter” to try to get cheap applause and laughter. Every time I’ve turned to watch SNL the last 5 years I havn’t found myself laughing. It used to be backwards for me. I used to Hate MAD TV and love SNL. I switched when I realized SNL had no more “clever” humor to offer. Let’s see if SNL will bounce back now that Tina Fey has left. Thanks